"One way to see the unacceptability of welfare-independent rights is to ask the question ‘why Right X?’ to a very ultimate level. If the answer is ‘Right X because Y’, then one should ask ‘Why Y?’ For example, if the answer to ‘why free speech?’ is that people enjoy free speech, it is already not welfare-independent. If the answer is free speech deters dictatorship’, then we should ask, ‘Why is it desirable to deter dictatorship?’ If one presses hard enough with such questions, most people will eventually come up with a welfare-related answer."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Yew-Kwang Ng, Welfarism and Utilitarianism: A Rehabilitation, Utilitas, 2(2): 180 (1990).
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Yew-Kwang_Ng
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Yew-Kwang Ng
13 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Yew-Kwang Ng →
Related Quotes
"I myself regard enjoyment and suffering (defined more broadly to include milder pain and discomfort) as not only the …"
"I have also no difficulties saying that my welfare level is positive, zero, or negative. When I am neither enjoying n…"
"Though […] feelings are subjective to the sentient concerned, they exist objectively. That my toothache is subjective…"
"[T]he real per capita income of the world now is about 7-8 times that of a century ago. If we proceed along an enviro…"
"[W]hile the problem of interpersonal comparability of utility is a tricky one, it is not insoluble in principle. It i…"
"As there are many areas of inadequate optimization (departures), and resource limitation and information costs preven…"
"With adequate safeguards and cautious preparation, genetic engineering could be used to relieve suffering and increas…"
"In my view...intrinsically, happiness is the only thing that is of value. Other things may have instrumental value. F…"
"In China, until about 100 years ago people believed that if your husband died, no matter how young you were, you coul…"
"When people’s income are low and at the survival, starvation level, then having enough to eat just to survive is very…"