"To understand why this welfare system persists, we need to acknowledge that at its root, targeting and its attendant exclusions are ultimately also justified and sustained by a sense of suspicion that implicates both the public and the state’s own functionaries. So, delivery is designed on the assumption that dominant local elites and intermediaries — who will otherwise use every opportunity to exploit the poor and while diverting and extracting entitlements and benefits — must be, at least in theory, excluded and bypassed. The poor themselves, even if materially deprived, are often cast as morally undeserving, susceptible to manipulation, expedient, and irresponsible (one only had to witness the discourse around Monday’s nationwide run on liquor stores for proof). And finally, that corrupt and rent-seeking bureaucrats and who only work the system rather than keep it working must have their discretion clipped. The result is a welfare architecture that is so invested in minimising errors of inclusion that it continuously chooses fiscal, bureaucratic and technological ‘solutions’ that systematically enable ‘errors of exclusion’ to multiply."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Mekhala Krishnamurthy, Flaws of India’s welfare system are visible in our fight against Covid-19 (8 May, 2020), co-written with Arkaja Singh,
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Welfare_in_India
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Welfare in India
5 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Welfare in India →
Related Quotes
"The current welfare system cannot deal with the Covid-19 crisis. [...] During a humanitarian crisis of this magnitude…"
"The lockdown and its humanitarian consequences have begun to fundamentally challenge the mind-set and modalities of I…"
"Today, a pandemic. Tomorrow, a natural disaster, a chemical spill or some . There’s always some disruption around the…"
"The vast sums spent by the State in maintaining pauper houses and in scattering alms during Ramzan and other holy day…"
"Despite the annual embarrassment of India scoring a poor rank on the , nutrition and hunger hardly merit a mention in…"
"Most towns in Hindustan are made up of earth, mud, and other wretched material; that there is no city or town (that) …"
"One has only to read Bhimsen’s graphic account of the miserable conditions in the Deccan as a result of Qurangzeb’s r…"
"I had been astonished, since I left Bicholim [eight miles north of Goa], to find the roads crowded with troops of peo…"
"An important order in the reign of Aurangzeb describes the Jagirdars as demanding in theory only half but in practice…"
"The conclusion that the decay noticed in the early 19th century and more so in subsequent decades originated with Eur…"