"Compatibility, not incompatibility, is the issue. For pc set 'analysis' is incompatible with nothing, as the fact of its universal potential applicability already testifies. It begins not with observation of musical particularities but with a universe of possibilities. The comparison of any musical entity with such a universe yields an inexhaustible quarry of 'true facts' but no criterion of relevance. As long as not such criterion has been established… the endless stream of ostensible relations stemming from the pc survey can persuade us for a while that analysis is being accomplished. But in fact it is only a tabulation that can just as well be carried on in the presense of analysis as in its absence (hence the universal 'compatibility'). Nor is it really so innocuous as I may be making it seem, since in its anodyne effect (one never comes back from the fishing expedition empty-handed, there is always 'something to say' some 'finding' to report) it can deflect attention away from the task at hand, which is to formulate analytical methods, not concoct a universal solvent."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Taruskin, Richard. "Reply to van den Toorn", p. 57.
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Richard_Taruskin
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Richard Taruskin
Richard Taruskin (April 2, 1945 – July 1, 2022) was an American musicologist, music historian, and critic who has written about the theory of performance, Russian music, 15th-century music, 20th-century music, nationalism, the theory of modernism, and analysis.
2 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Richard Taruskin →
Related Quotes
"The nice thing about an -ism, someone once observed, is how quickly it becomes a wasm. Some musical wasms—academic-wa…"
"In all human undertakings the period of growth is followed by one of decay unless a new spirit pours fresh life into …"
"When completely dry the plant should be mounted on stiff white paper. The size depends on the purpose of the collecti…"
"That the was the predecessor and counterpart of the of the present day is a matter of common knowledge, but, when we …"
"Of ancient stringed instruments there are, we may roughly say, two broad types; in one the strings are stretched acro…"
"Sir (Ur Excavations, vol. , 1934) records that in the grave of the (c. 2700 ) he notices close to the coffin a quanti…"
"At present...I feel that my works require a modified serial technique, but it is a very unorthodox one, and almost ne…"
"I don’t understand any music! I feel it. I want them to feel something! I don’t want them to understand it. If I want…"
"I have one idea about this whole interpretation problem as it relates to orchestral music — too many of our conductor…"
"To me, the wonderful thing about music is a love affair between the performer and the composer, and between the compo…"