"What strikes me as particularly undeniable is that the absence of the feeling of belonging to a class is characteristic of children of the bourgeoisie. People in a dominant class position do not notice that they are positioned, situated, within a specific world (just as someone who is white isn’t necessarily aware of being so, or someone heterosexual). Read in this light, Aron’s remark can be seen for what it is, the naive confession offered by a person of privilege who imagines he is writing sociology when all he is doing is describing his own social status. I only met him once in my life, and immediately felt a strong aversion towards him. The very moment I set eyes on him, I loathed his ingratiating smile, his soothing voice, his way of demonstrating how reasonable and rational he was, everything about him that displayed his bourgeois ethos of decorum and propriety, of ideological moderation. (In reality, his writings are filled with a violence that those at whom it is directed would not be able to avoid feeling were they ever to come across it. It suffices to read—but there are other choices too—the pages he wrote about the working-class strikes in the 1950s. People have praised his lucidity because he was anticommunist while others still blindly supported the Soviet Union. But this is wrong! He was anticommunist because of his hatred of the working class, and he set himself up as the political and ideological defender of the bourgeois establishment, defending against anything having to do with the aspirations or the political activities of the working class. Basically, his pen was for hire: he was a soldier in the service of those in power helping them to maintain their power. Sartre was right a thousand times over to insult him in May 1968. Aron had more than earned it. Let us salute the greatness of Sartre for daring to break with the conventions of polite academic “discussion”—which always works in favor of “orthodoxy,” and its reliance on “common sense” and what seems “self-evident” in its opposition to heterodoxy and to critical thought. Sartre did this at a moment when it had become important to “insult those who are the real insulters,” to recall a helpful reminder Genet offers us, a happy turn of phrase we should always be ready to take up as our motto.)"
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Academics from FrancePhilosophers from FranceJournalists from FranceSociologists from FrancePolitical scientists from France
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Didier Eridon, Returning to Reims (2009) (Translated by Michael Lucey)
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Raymond_Aron
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Raymond Aron
Raymond-Claude-Ferdinand Aron (14 March 1905 – 17 October 1983) was a French philosopher, sociologist, journalist, and political scientist.
6 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Raymond Aron →
Related Quotes
"The optimism of the Left was created and maintained by a strong feeling: admiration for the power of reason, certaint…"
"The man who no longer expects miraculous changes either from a revolution or from an economic plan is not obliged to …"
"The intellectual ... must try never to forget the arguments of the adversary, or the uncertainty of the future, or th…"
"In short, Raymond Aron was a perfect bourgeois. I use the term invented by liberal democracy's critics and enemies to…"
"Like the Owl of Minerva, Aron brought wisdom to the French intellectual community in its twilight years; but the bela…"
"Ce temps, si court, a des langueurs mortelles Quand l'âme oisive en compte les instans: C'est le travail qui lui donn…"
"Dans les espaces immenses de l'erreur, la vérité n'est qu'un point. Qui l'a saisi, ce point unique?"
"Il n'est pas permis Ă tous les hommes d'ĂŞtre grands, mais ils peuvent tous ĂŞtre bons."
"L'éloquence est dans l'âme, et non dans la parole."
"Le ciel, l'enfer sont dans le cœur de l'homme."