"Every attempt, then, to give absolute dates for 'Proto-Indo-European' (or dates for alleged different stages of'PIE') is either based on the speculative identification of an archaeological culture with the speakers of the 'language of the PIE's' or on what may be called 'intelligent guesses,' deliberations of probability and feelings of appropriateness. ... The first type of proposal is usually contested by fellow archaeologists and doubted by linguists, the second, being purely subjective because objective arguments simply do not exist, is bound to remain noncommittal. As is easily to be seen, many dates of both types have found their way to an often far too skeptical public."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Zimmer, Stefan. 1988. "On Dating Indo-European: A Call for Honesty." Journal of Indo-European Studies 16:371-375. 372-5 Zimmer (1988), quoted in Bryant, E. F. (2001). The Quest for the Origins of Vedic Culture : the Indo-Aryan migration debate. Oxford University Press. chapter 12
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Proto-Indo-European_language
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Proto-Indo-European language
16 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Proto-Indo-European language →
Related Quotes
"We must not make the mistake of confusing our methods, and the results flowing from them, with the facts; we must not…"
"We now find ourselves in possession of two entirely different items, both of which we call Proto-Indo-European: one, …"
"Arguing about 'Proto-Indo-European' can be meaningful and fruitful . . . if we always explain whether we are talking …"
"It now strikes me that the attempt to reconstruct a prototypical (“Proto- Indo-European") form from which all atteste…"
"It is an elementary mistake to equate common Indo-European words with Proto-Indo- European words and to base thereon …"
"No reputable linguist pretends that Proto-Indo-European reconstructions represent a reality, and the unpronounceabili…"
"A sheep that had no wool saw horses, one of them pulling a heavy wagon, one carrying a big load, and one carrying a m…"
"It must be stressed, and cannot be said often enough, that whatever date is given for 'PIE,' it is necessarily no mor…"
"It is therefore historically irresponsible for the linguist to speak of 'Proto-Indo-European' in the 4th millennium, …"
"To be sure, neither Jones nor anyone else was wrong to perceive strong and systematic similarities among Sanskrit, La…"