"All Catholic priests cannot be universally characterized in terms of personality and psychological functioning. Like many vocations and professions, a wide variety of individuals choose to become Catholic priests and a range of personality styles and levels of psychological health are represented in the priesthood. However, a fairly small number of research studies have investigated the psychological profiles of Catholic clergy or Catholic seminary students in an effort to better understand the psychological and personality functioning of these individuals (e.g., Banks, Mooney, Mucowski, & Williams, 1984; Bier, 1948; Keddy, Erdberg, & Sammon, 1990; McCarthy, 1942; Weisgerber, 1966). More studies have examined the psychological profiles of non-Catholic clergy such as Protestant ministers (e.g., Ashbrook & Powell, 1967; Ekhardt & Goldsmith, 1984; Patrick, 1990, 1991). The vast majority of these investigations have used the MMPI to assess personality and psychological functioning and the majority of these projects were conducted prior to 1980. However, a review of these and more recent studies indicate that specific clergy personality trends based on group data have surfaced. As part of a comprehensive review of the literature, Nauss (1973) investigated MMPI p~roflles of nine Protestant and two Catholic studies and found "... an amazing similarity..." (p. 84) and a "... high degree of uniformity among MMPI results.., suggest(ing) an easily identifiable pattern" (p. 89) with elevations on the K, Hy, Pd, Mr, and Ma scales and low scores on the Si scale. Nauss described the ministerial personality as being characterized by "... extroversion, reflectiveness or intuitiveness, nurturance, and co-operation, and environment ordering" (p. 89). Nanss further noted that Catholic seminary students tended to be more introverted than Protestants."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
No categories assigned
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Thomas G. Plante, Gerdenio Manuel, and Jeannette Tandez; “Personality Characteristics of Successful Applicants to the Priesthood”, Pastoral Psychology, Vol 45, No. 1, 1996, p. 30.
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Priesthood_in_the_Catholic_Church
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Priesthood in the Catholic Church
14 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Priesthood in the Catholic Church →
Related Quotes
"However, nobody can be surprised that the priests, the bishops, and the popes of Rome are sunk into such a bottomless…"
"A vast number of Catholic clerics have been tried for sexual crimes ... It is not a matter of regrettable individual …"
"Some have suggested that priests and applicants to the priesthood too often experience psychological dysfunction (e.g…"
"The Church and society in general have changed a great deal since the 1973 review by Nauss and many wonder if applica…"
"Keddy et al. (1990) found elevated L scales on the MMPI, suggesting priests often maintain defensive styles, while Du…"
"The postwar debate on mandatory clerical celibacy in the Catholic Church did not begin in earnest until 1968. Against…"
"To understand the post-World War Ii celibacy debate, some information on the meaning the Catholic Church assigns to c…"
"Untainted by sexual intercourse, the priest was a man apart from and above his congregation. Franz Franken, a laicize…"
"The Latin Church has not always demanded celibacy or continence of its priests. There is evidence that, beginning in …"
"In Optatam Totius, the council fathers encouraged bishops to consider the results and methods of psychology in the re…"