"We already dealt with this possibility earlier: ‘This may be contrasted with the situation farther east in the Ganga plain, where we do find many Sanskrit-sounding names of rivers and regions which do not have a transparent Sanskrit etymology, for example, kauśikī or kośala, apparently linked to Tibeto-Burmese kosi, “water”, and the name of the river separating Kośala from Videha. In that case, we also see the ongoing sanskritization: kauśikī evolved from kosikī (attested in Pali), and kośala from kosala (idem), which Witzel (1999a: 382) considers as necessarily foreign loans because the sequence -os- is “not allowed in Sanskrit”. But while the phonetic assimilation is caught in the act here, we can see no semantic domestication through folk etymology at work. The name kośala doesn’t mean anything in Sanskrit, and that is a decisive difference with the western hydronyms gomatī, “the cow-rich one”, or asiknī, “the dark one”. While the occurrence of some folk-etymological adaptation among the Panjabi river names could in principle be conceded, it is highly unlikely to be the explanation of all thirty-five names. Until proof to the contrary, the evidence of the Northwest-Indian hydronyms favours the absence of a non-IE substratum, hence of the OIT.’ (Elst 2005:242)"
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Place names in India
11 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Place names in India →
Related Quotes
"So many names that at a hasty glance appear utterly unmeaning can be traced back to original Sanskrit forms as to rai…"
"The non-Indo-Aryan nature of the terms and names noted earlier also has to be juxtaposed with the fact that the place…"
"And curiously, an astonishing number of names of towns and villages in western Rajasthan (the heart of the Thar Deser…"
"Northern India is the only place where place-names and river-names are Indo-European right from the period of the Rig…"
"The local river names and animal names in the Old Rigveda are purely Indo-Aryan names. This phenomenon is noted even …"
"The non-Indo-Aryan nature of the terms and names noted earlier also has to be juxtaposed with the fact that the place…"
"With this in mind, it is significant that there are very few non-Indo-Aryan names for rivers and places in the North …"
"The lack of foreign place-names in the oldest Indo-Aryan texts, in contrast, is remarkable when compared with the dur…"
"In view of the fact that Witzel has provided a list of thirty-seven different Vedic river names, these two or three p…"
"Many of die foreign terms for flora and fauna could simply indicate that these items have continually been imported i…"