"Julian Gough's] notion that shouting the word 'feck' – Father Ted has a lot to answer for – and being grossly scatological will make him seem echt Irish only harms his argument. We who were born and continue to live in Ireland are always distressed by the stage-Irish antics so often to be encountered among the sons and daughters of the diaspora. But it is true, as the critic Declan Kiberd remarks, that no contemporary Irish writer has yet attempted the Great Irish Novel on social and political themes. Where is our Middlemarch, our Doctor Zhivago, our Rabbit trilogy? The fact is Irish fiction tends to be poetic rather than prosaic, which is something that non-Irish reviewers find hard to grasp. John McGahern used to say that there is verse and there is prose, and then there is poetry, and poetry can occur in either form, and that in Ireland it occurs more often in prose than in verse. There may be a grittily realistic novelist even now writing a masterpiece such as Mr Gough says he longs for, and, if so, I applaud her/him."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Novelists from IrelandPostmodern authorsBooker Prize winnersJournalists from IrelandRecipients of the Franz Kafka Prize
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Julian Gough slams fellow Irish novelists as 'priestly caste' cut off from the culture, The Guardian (11 February 2010).
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/John_Banville
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
John Banville
107 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by John Banville →
Related Quotes
"When I think back to then, from out of this sepulchral silence, I am aware of a ceaseless hubbub of voices loudly say…"
"Man is only lovable in the multitude, and at a good distance."
"I was pondering the question, which I have pondered before, of whether such great revelatory moments really so occur,…"
"I have tried to explain to her that the concept of bravery is entirely spurious. We are what we are, we do what we do."
"Ah, what heights of contempt I was capable of in those days! Now, in old age, I have largely lost that faculty, and I…"
"I have always disliked the sea, its surliness, its menace, its vast reaches and unknowable, shudder-inducing depths."
"Diderot said that what we do is, we erect a statue in our own image inside ourselves—idealised, you know, but still r…"
"But what comfort does belief offer, when it contains within it its own antithesis, the glistening drop of poison at t…"
"I suspect that significant first encounters only take on their aura of significance in retrospect."
"I would have failed, of course, but failure is the condition of the artist's life. What kind of failure would I have …"