"The solution, as we will see, is to treat the Noble Savage as a discursive construct and to begin with a rigorous examination of occurrences of the rhetoric of nobility as it was applied by ethnographic and other European writers to the peoples they labeled “savages.” In focusing on the discursive rather than the substantive Noble Savage, which might be imagined to lurk behind any positive reference to “savages” anywhere in the literature, we will find that the term “Noble Savage” was invented in 1609, nearly a century and a half before Rousseau, by Marc Lescarbot, a French lawyer-ethnographer, as a concept in comparative law. We will see the concept of the Noble Savage virtually disappear for more than two hundred years, without reemerging in Rousseau or his contemporaries, until it is finally resurrected in 1859 by John Crawfurd, soon to become president of the Ethnological Society of London, as part of a racist coup within the society. It is Crawfurd’s construction, framed as part of a program of ideological support for an attack on anthropological advocacy of human rights, that creates the myth as we know it, including the false attribution of authorship to Rousseau; and Crawfurd’s version becomes the source for every citation of the myth by anthropologists from Lubbock, Tylor, and Boas through the scholars of the late twentieth century. The chronological sequence of the following chapters also conceals the process followed in my own investigation of the myth. In fact, I began with a look at related historical problems in Rousseau’s writings. Having absorbed the myth as part of my professional training, I was at first incidentally surprised and then increasingly disturbed by not finding evidence of either the discursive or the substantive Noble Savage in Rousseau’s works. Finding this an interesting problem in its own right, I began to explore the secondary literature on the subject, beginning with Hoxie Neale Fairchild’s The Noble Savage (1928), finding confirmation of my readings of Rousseau but no satisfactory investigation of the myth’s real source."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Ter Ellingson, The Myth of the Noble Savage (2001), pp. xv-xvi
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Jean-Jacques_Rousseau_and_noble_savage
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Jean-Jacques Rousseau and noble savage
6 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Jean-Jacques Rousseau and noble savage →
Related Quotes
"The best-known expression of the idea of the ‘noble savage’ is in Rousseau’s A Discourse on Inequality (1755). The co…"
"The Maori of New Zealand committed massacres regularly. The dyaks of Borneo were headhunters. The Polynesians, living…"
"As far as the noble savage is concerned, that phrase is from Dryden and does not appear in Rousseau’s writings. In th…"
"Rousseau, like Hobbes, asserted the natural equality of mankind but saw humans in their natural state as being (justl…"
"The notion that Rousseau’s Discourse on Inequality was essentially a glorification of the State of Nature, and that i…"
"There are many dark chapters in mankind's history ranging from transatlantic slave trade to holocaust to dropping of …"
"Intensive studies of individual tribes are very important and I think ASI (ie. the Anthropological Survey of India) w…"
"What is now required is a carefully and scientifically edited Dictionary or Gazetteer of the Castes, and Tribes, and …"
"I am not free as long as one person of Color remains chained. Nor is any one of you."
"The Laiharaoba is the bedrock on which the entire Meitei civilization rests."