"The modem federal immigration power, which is commonly known as the "plenary power doctrine," is defined by two features. First, Congress's authority to regulate immigration derives not from any constitutionally enumerated power, but is rather "an incident of sovereignty belonging to the government of the United States." Second, federal laws or enforcement actions that bear on a non-citizen's right to be present within the country are buffered against judicially enforceable constitutional constraints. The extent to which governmental authority is constitutionally constrained is thus contingent on the citizenship status of the person who is subject to that authority, rather than (as would normally be the case) the subject-matter or purpose of the regulation involved. This is true even when the constitutional protection at issue-be it the First Amendment or the Due Process and Equal Protection Clauses-makes no distinction between "persons" and "citizens." Indeed, even as Justice Frankfurter upheld Juan Galvan's deportation, he was struck by "a sense of harsh incongruity" between the principle that "the Due Process Clause[normally] qualifies the scope of [Congress's] political discretion" and the deportation of a long-term resident alien who was innocent of any wrong-doing. Ever since the Supreme Court first adopted the plenary power doctrine in the 1889 Chinese Exclusion Case, so it has justified the "constitutional exceptionalism" " of American immigration law with reference to the purportedly intricate connection between the admission and removal of foreigners and "basic aspects of national sovereignty, more particularly our foreign relations and the national security.,""
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
p.746
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Immigration_to_the_United_States
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Immigration to the United States
279 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Immigration to the United States →
Related Quotes
"As part of its commitment to human rights, the United States offers asylum to foreign nation-als who flee to its shor…"
"The narrative of immigration as regeneration imagined the republican system itself, as well the economic arrangements…"
"Immigrants were legally reconstructed as foreigners only in the final decades of the nineteenth century, as Europeans…"
"Human judgment can never be eliminated from any system of justice. But we believe that the outcome of a refugee’s que…"
"If the adoption of the Alien Friends Act represented a dramatic short-term political triumph for the Federalist Party…"
"The history of immigration law and politics in the nineteenth century is, in an important respect, a history of repea…"
"Although the fact that the Constitution vests the authority to enact naturalization laws in Congress suggests that so…"
"Collectively, asylum officers, immigration judges, members of the Board of Immigration Appeals, and judges of U.S. co…"
"In crafting a naturalization law, prudence thus counseled that immigrants undergo a period of probation before being …"
"Over the first half of the nineteenth century, even as Americans developed progressively sharper critiques of immigra…"