"One of the problems that has most beset the study of early medieval Europe is, as noted, that of Germanism. This book aims to tackle this issue... To lump all Germanic-speaking tribes together is simply to repeat the assumptions of Roman ethnographers or the politically contingent Germanist interpretations of the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. There is, furthermore, the danger of assuming a linkage between Germanic-speaking barbarians of antiquity and the Germans of modern Europe. This was an approach adopted equally by nineteenth-century historians working in the context of German unification, by the Nazis and at the same time, polemically, by their enemies... [T]here are many occasions where modern historians and, especially, archaeologists, treat the different Germanic-speaking groups as sharing some sort of unifying ethos... It is implicit in such interpretations that all ‘Germanic’ peoples somehow share a common mentality. In their minds is a common stock of cultural traits which all ‘Germanic’ people can draw upon as and when they see fit. This may be claimed to be a reductio ad absurdam of traditional assumptions. It is, but only because these assumptions are fundamentally absurd."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Historians from EnglandEssayists from EnglandAcademics from the United KingdomNon-fiction authors from England
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
pp. 22-23
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Guy_Halsall
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Guy Halsall
12 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Guy Halsall →
Related Quotes
"In the reinterpretation of ‘Germanic’ archaeology I have benefited from discussions with, and the encouragement of fe…"
"The problems of Germanism have long been recognised. Alas, entirely analogous developments are currently taking place…"
"There can be no question of a general overriding ‘Germanic’ or ‘Celtic’ identity amongst the different barbarian grou…"
"Historians are not immune from similarly bizarre reasoning, of course. The counter-revisionist offensive against more…"
"The Nazis adopted these ideas with gusto but they did not invent them. Nor have post-Nazi archaeologists entirely aba…"
"[I'm] (probably) the most significant historian of early medieval Europe under the age of 60 anywhere in the world...…"
"Recently, something of an academic counter-revolution... has taken place. Oxford-trained historians have led the way,…"
"The recent use of scientific (or pseudo-scientific) methodologies to examine migration has added an extra, alarming d…"
"[T]he writing of history is inescapably political, my aim is partly to provide a basis for a more politically and eth…"
"The first part of the essay calls into question the idea that the Germanic-speaking barbarians shared any sort of uni…"