"Well, I must confess that I haven't read all of Giampaolo Pansa's books thoroughly because I feel nauseous when I pick them up, but I know more or less how they are perceived by those who read them. We cannot get inside Giampaolo Pansa's head, so we cannot know whether this man, who used to be a left-winger, had a change of heart at some point and really said to himself: the defeated deserve to be remembered... an injustice has been done in Italy... Whether he realised the effect his books were having, or whether he realised it but cynically carried on because they made him a lot of money. We can no longer say; certainly the books are despicable, not because they may contain inaccuracies [...]. But I would not be at all surprised if these books only reported authentic episodes, because it has always been known in Italy that obviously anything could have happened in the Resistance. These are things that even in the 1950s the fascists, who incidentally were perfectly free in a democracy to publish books in which they recounted these things, so everyone already knew about them even before. [...] So, dramatic episodes? Tragic? Crimes? Crimes committed by partisans with the authorisation of the Allied authorities, who generally told the partisans to “clean up”? Who can say it doesn't matter? Of course, it is always a tragedy, but if we look at the crimes committed by the liberators, then what? The armies that marched up the peninsula committed crimes against the civilian population, against prisoners of war... Ever since they landed in Sicily, and yet the people of Italian cities welcomed them jubilantly, happy that they had arrived. So, the problem is that you can always find individual episodes in any context to put anyone in a good or bad light: what matters is who was on the right side and who was on the wrong side. And I challenge anyone today who turns up their nose at the partisans or has Pansa's books on their bookshelf in plain view to say: 'But would you have preferred the others to win? Would you want to live in a world where Hitler had won? And where the gas chambers would have continued to operate? Really? If you tell me that sincerely, I'm fine with it, okay. But I want to see which readers of Pansa's books would answer yes to that question."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Giampaolo Pansa
1935 – 2020
Giampaolo Pansa (1935–2020) was an Italian journalist, writer, and historian.
34 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Giampaolo Pansa →
Related Quotes
"With your departure, that world has ended completely. For a week now, I have been trying not to think that you, dear …"
"The hardest [defeat] came in 2014 when Matteo Renzi's government, which had been in office for a few weeks, dismissed…"
"Giorgio Bocca can be summed up in a few words. He was a great journalist, but also highly partisan and prone to serio…"
"The left wing party has always told lies, starting with the invasion of Hungary and continuing through the Popular Fr…"
"A yellow-green government? It is not a trivial center-right government, but a government of terrorists. A terrorist g…"
"Reporter: If you waited a little longer to write, everything would have disappeared. Some say that oblivion is better…"
"Words can turn into stones, stones into bullets. It has already happened: Italy was held captive by terrorism for alm…"
"Someone said of Sergio Mattarella: in politics, he is tenacious and persistent, like a falling drop of water."
"When I hear Grillo shouting, Italians, it sends a chill down my spine, because it reminds me of someone who shouted t…"
"There is a shy Ciriaco De Mita. And also a grumpy De Mita. And then there is the introverted De Mita. He is not easy …"