"Closely connected with the foregoing is the fallacy of the Complex Question. By a complex question, in the broadest meaning of that term, is meant one that suggests its own answer. Any question, for instance, that forces us to select, and assert in our answer to it, one of the elements of the question itself, while some other possibility is really open, is complex in the sense in which that term is here employed. If, for example, one were to ask… if your favourite colour were red or blue, or if you had given up a particular bad habit, he would be guilty of the fallacy of the complex question, if, in each case, the alternatives, as a matter of fact, were more numerous than, or were in any way different from, those stated in the question. Any leading question which complicates an issue by over simplification is fallacious for the same reason. Now, in the light of what we have said with respect to the petitio principii, it is not difficult to see that the fallacy of the complex question is occasioned by the character of the assumption on which the question rests. In the petitio principii an assumption with respect to the subject-matter of an argument functions as a premise, in the complex question it is a similar assumption that shuts out some of the material possibilities of a situation and confines an issue within too narrow limits. As in the former case, so here, the only way of meeting the difficulty is to raise the previous question, that is, to call the assumption which lies back of the fallacy into question."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Arthur Ernest Davies (1915) A Text-Book of Logic. R.G. Adams and company. p. 569-576.
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Fallacy
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Fallacy
33 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Fallacy →
Related Quotes
"A Fallacy, or Sophism, is a false argument; or else an argument leading to a false conclusion. The use of such argume…"
"Fallacy: An argument which seems conclusive, but is not so, is fallacious ; that is to say, deceptive. When such fall…"
"FALLACY is a logical term; but in the consideration of the ideas denoted by it, we are led, at several points, beyond…"
"In the case of any person whose judgment is really deserving of confidence, how has it become so? Because he has kept…"
"All the fallacies of human reason had to be exhausted, before the light of a high truth could meet with ready accepta…"
"There is always hope of a man so long as he dwells in the region of the direct categorical proposition and the unambi…"
"Fools! Do you argue, that things ancient ought, on that account, to be true and noble! Fallacies and Falsehoods there…"
"This fallacy [appeal to authority] is not in itself an error; it is impossible to learn much in today’s world without…"
"Utility and necessity of logic - It would be a mistake to imagine that, above and beyond what is called the Natural L…"
"The easiest and most popular way of practically refuting... any Fallacy is, by bringing forward a parallel case, wher…"