"There are many ways that reviewing can be dishonest. Here is one illustration, drawn from no less a personnage than the self-appointed doyen of the literature dons, Terry Eagleton. A standard rhetorical device in discursive literature has the form “some say X, but I say Y.” The author might not disagree with X, but thinks Y is the more important point. A scurrilous reviewer can systematically misrepresent the author by saying, “the author says X” and omitting the author’s rider “Y”. This is one of Eagleton’s techniques of choice (chapter and verse can be abundantly supplied). Of course, this might not be intentional on Eagleton’s part; he might merely be stupid or lazy. But since it is better to doubt this, we have to conclude instead that he is guilty of wilful misrepresentation. It is alarming to think that such are the ethics of criticism he teaches his students at Manchester University."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Cultural criticsSocial criticsPhilosophers from the United KingdomLogicians from the United KingdomUniversity of Oxford faculty
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Chapter 55, “Reading and Reviewing” (p. 208)
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/A._C._Grayling
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
A. C. Grayling
58 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by A. C. Grayling →
Related Quotes
"Of all the questions we can ask ourselves the most important is: how is one best to live?"
"A civilized society is one which never ceases having a discussion with itself about what human life should best be."
"Folly tends to predominate over wisdom because it is usually easier to understand and more convenient (or exciting) t…"
"The media no longer hesitate to whip up lurid anxieties in order to increase sales, in the process undermining social…"
"Moral panics occur because the increased availability of information about what happens in our society is not matched…"
"New and challenging moral dilemmas are always likely to arise, so we need to try to make ourselves the kind of people…"
"Emancipation is always at risk from the usual sources—demagogues, civil and international war, the tenure that supers…"
"The claim is that educating moral sensibility through imagination has a general tendency, not a universal effect."
"Symbols have the unfortunate power to acquire the importance of what they symbolise."
"On the best view, justice is fairness."