"While collective memory is usually grounded in fact, it need not be. If you go to China, you will more than likely be told the story of the park in the foreign concession area of Shanghai that had on its gate a sign that read “Dogs and Chinese Not Admitted.” While it is true that the park was reserved for foreigners, insulting enough in itself, the real insult for most Chinese was their pairing with dogs. The only trouble is that there is no evidence the sign ever existed. When young Chinese historians expressed some doubts about the story in 1994, the official press reacted with anger. “Some people,” a well-known journalist wrote, “do not understand the humiliations of old Chinas history or else they harbour sceptical attitudes and even go so far as to write off serious historical humiliation lightly; this is very dangerous.” It can be dangerous to question the stories people tell about themselves because so much of our identity is both shaped by and bound up with our past history. That is why dealing with the past, in deciding on which version we want, or on what we want to remember and to forget, can become so politically charged."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Margaret MacMillan, The Uses and Abuses of History (2008), pp. 52-53
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Shanghai
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Shanghai
6 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Shanghai →
Related Quotes
"Bizarre advertising displays—the honour guard of fifty Chinese hunchbacks outside the film premiere of The Hunchback …"
"With its newspapers and radio stations in every language, Shanghai was a media city before its time, celebrated as th…"
"I would see something strange and mysterious, and treat it as normal ... Shanghai struck me as a magical place, a sel…"
"China as a society, a government, an economy and a culture is quite difficult for us to comprehend today. The changes…"
"This city is a completely female city. Female town. Beijing is male. All rough and politics. Shanghai is more delicat…"
"Shenzhen is shouldering the weight of innovation to achieve Chinese tech breakthroughs in strategic industries while …"
"As China’s pre-eminent tech hub, Shenzhen is home to industry giants such as Huawei Technologies, BYD and DJI. Yet, d…"
"The southern city where China’s economic transformation began more than four decades ago, and which has seen its hi-t…"
"Shenzhen, with fewer than 30,000 inhabitants scattered in a number of small village clusters, made history as China’s…"
"Shenzhen is a city built on migrant labour. The government there has always adopted policies that adapt to that fact.…"