"The new vision of man and politics was never taken by its founders to be splendid. Naked man, gripped by fear or industriously laboring to provide the wherewithal for survival, is not an apt subject for poetry. They self-consciously chose low but solid ground. Civil societies dedicated to the end of self-preservation cannot be expected to provide fertile soil for the heroic and inspired. They do not require or encourage the noble. What rules and sets the standards of respectability and emulation is not virtue or wisdom. The recognition of the humdrum and prosaic character of life was intended to play a central role in the success of real politics. And the understanding of human nature which makes this whole project feasible, if believed in, clearly forms a world in which the higher motives have no place. One who holds the “economic” view of man cannot consistently believe in the dignity of man or in the special status of art and science. The success of the enterprise depends precisely on this simplification of man. And if there is a solution to the human problems, there is no tragedy. There was no expectation that, after the bodily needs are taken care of, man would have a spiritual renaissance—and this for two reasons: (1) men will always be mortal, which means that there can be no end to the desire for immortality and to the quest for means to achieve it; and (2) the premise of the whole undertaking is that man’s natural primary concern is preservation and prosperity; the regimes founded on nature take man as he is naturally and will make him ever more natural. If his motives were to change, the machinery that makes modern government work would collapse."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Philosophers from the United StatesEssayists from the United StatesEducators from the United StatesHistorians from the United StatesCultural critics
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
“Commerce and Culture,” p. 284.
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Allan_Bloom
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Allan Bloom
Allan David Bloom (14 September, 1930 in Indianapolis, Indiana – 7 October, 1992 in Chicago, Illinois) was an American philosopher, essayist and academic. Bloom championed education based on the study of 'Great Books', as did his mentor Leo Strauss. He criticised contemporary American higher education in his 1987 book, The Closing of the American Mind, whic
28 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Allan Bloom →
Related Quotes
"Students have powerful images of what a perfect body is and pursue it incessantly. But deprived of literary guidance,…"
"There are two threats to reason, the opinion that one knows the truth about the most important things and the opinion…"
"Socrates’ way of life is the consequence of his recognition that we can know what it is that we do not know about the…"
"I am now even more persuaded of the urgent need to study why Socrates was accused. The dislike of philosophy is peren…"
"Only the search back to the origins of one’s ideas in order to see the real arguments for them, before people became …"
"To recognize that some of the things our culture believes are not true imposes on us the duty of finding out which ar…"
"Only when the true ends of society have nothing to do with the sublime does “culture” become necessary as a veneer to…"
"The distinction between private and public undermines the unity of spiritual strength, draining the public of the tra…"
"Intellectuals … advertise their superiority to political practice but are absolutely in its thrall. … It is no accide…"
"There are two kinds of openness, the openness of indifference—promoted with the twin purposes of humbling our intelle…"