"Where Kuzmina finds Andronovo archaeological prototypes for the inferred Indo-Aryan cultural equipment known by the Mitanni Syria in the Near East and the Vedic speakers in India, Klejn points out that no actual trace of this Andronovo culture in the archaeology of either of these-Indo-Aryan cultures in the Near East or India has come to light. Klejn's critique of this Andronovo hypothesis raises important objections. While acknowledging the Iranian identification of the Andronovo culture, he finds it much too late for an Indo-Aryan identification, since the Andronovo culture "took shape in the 16th or 17th century B.c, whereas the Aryans already appeared in the Near East not later than the 1 5th to 16th century B.C." More important, "these [latter] regions contain nothing reminiscent of Timber-Frame Andronovo materials" (Klejn 1974, 58). This is an essential point, especially since, as we have seen, some scholars date the Indo-Aryan presence in the Near East to the 18th or 17th century B.C.E. How, then, could the Indo- Aryans have been represented in a completely different material culture in the steppes at more or less the same time? An Indo-Iranian affiliation of the graves is even more unrealistic, since the joint Indo-Iranian period would have been much earlier than the dates for the Andronovo period. Brenties (1981), we can recall, pointed out the same objections with the Andronovo theory."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Klejn, L. 1984. "The Coming of the Aryans: Who and Whence?" Bulletin of the Deccan College Research Institute 43:57-72.
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Leo_Klejn
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Leo Klejn
Lev Samuilovich Kleyn (; 1 July 1927 – 7 November 2019), better known in English as Leo Klejn and Leo S. Klein, was a Russian archaeologist, anthropologist and philologist.
2 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Leo Klejn →
Related Quotes
"It is this evidence concerning the western contribution which persuaded workers to advocate the view that the Androno…"
"Abbreviations are the wheels of language, the wings of Mercury. And though we might be dragged along without them, it…"
"I never cared a bit for philology; my chief aim has been throughout to illustrate the social condition of the English…"
"Aux États-Unis la nature, comme la société, n'est pas toujours belle, mais elle est toujours grande."
"Since the normal tendency is to simplify, to trivialize, to eliminate the unfamiliar word or construction, the rule i…"
"Although Champollion was an avowed revolutionary and an enthusiastic Bonapartist, one of his earliest discoveries dis…"
"That classical philology received comparative linguistics with mistrust and doubt was very natural. The newborn young…"
"For what is more important and can be desired more urgently from the study of classical languages than the comparison…"
"They would not have it, they would not believe that there could be any community of origin between the people of Athe…"
"Though Bopp, by the end of his life, was an internationally respected and honored scholar, his was not a career witho…"