"Some think the way out of the [[w:Euthyphro dilemma|[Euthyphro] dilemma]] is to say that God just is good, so the question the dilemma poses is ill-formed. If God and good are the same thing then we cannot ask whether God chooses good because it is good – the very question separates what must come together. But the Euthyphro dilemma can be restated in another way to challenge this reply. We can ask, is God good because to be good just is to be whatever God is; or is God good because God has all the properties of goodness? If we choose the former answer we again find that goodness is arbitrary, since it would be whatever God happened to be, even if God were a sadist. So we must choose the second option: God is good because he has all the properties of goodness. But this means the properties of goodness can be specified independently of God and so the idea of goodness does not in any way depend upon the existence of God. Hence there is no reason why a denial of God's existence would necessarily entail a denial of the existence of goodness."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Julian Baggini, Atheism (New York: Sterling Publishing, 2009), p. 56
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Euthyphro
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Euthyphro
9 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Euthyphro →
Related Quotes
"Euthyphro: It is ridiculous, Socrates, for you to think that it makes any difference whether the victim is a stranger…"
"Euthyphro: Not only these, Socrates, but, as I was saying just now, I will, if you wish, relate many other things abo…"
"Euthyphro: Well then, what is dear to the gods is pious, what is not is impious. Socrates: Splendid, Euthyphro! You h…"
"Socrates: So you did not answer my question, you surprising man. I did not ask you what same thing is both pious and …"
"Socrates: …Is the pious being loved by the gods because it is pious, or is it pious because it is being loved by the …"
"Socrates: But if the god-loved and the pious were the same, my dear Euthyphro, then if the pious was being loved beca…"
"Socrates: Piety would then be a sort of trading skill between gods and men? Euthyphro: Trading yes, if you prefer to …"
"Socrates: So we must investigate again from the beginning what piety is, as I shall not willingly give up before I le…"
"Is not a Sophist, Hippocrates, one who deals wholesale or retail in the food of the soul? To me that appears to be hi…"
"Do you realize the sort of danger to which you are going to expose your soul? If it were a case of putting your body …"