"To see some really “inconsistent statements” and “cavalier” establishment of “divisions” of the composer families of the RV, the reader should read Witzel’s 1995 papers, where Witzel shows himself to be completely and (as his present statements show) irretrievably lost at sea (see pp. 446-449 OF MY BOOK): there, at one point, he “wants to limit the clans involved in the composition of the Rgvedic hymns” to only three families, the Vishvamitras, the Atris and the Angirases (in the third of which, he includes all the other Rishis); and, at another point, his broom sweeps all the Rishis in Mandala 8 into two “divisions”, the Kanva and the Angiras. At another, he counts the Vishvamitras in the Bhrgu family, and then goes on (in the absence of even the faintest hint to this effect anywhere in the RV, or even in any subsequent text) to place Vishvamitra at the head of the coalition against Sudas in the Dasharajna battle (not to mention minor(?) slip-ups like treating the Shaunakas as non-Bhargavas, and Ghora as a son or descendant of Kanva)!"
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Imported from EN Wikiquote
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Shrikant_Talageri
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Shrikant Talageri
Shrikant Talageri, born in 1958, was educated in Mumbai where he lives and works. He has devoted several years, and much to study, to the theory of an Aryan invasion of India, and interpreted the Vedas with the help of the internal chronology of Rig vedic Rishes within Rig Veda with the help of genealogical records Anukramanis.
118 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Shrikant Talageri →
Related Quotes
""Indian 'secularism' is basically a linear descendant of Leftist ideology, and derives its inspiration from Leftist t…"
""Muslims and Christians are not 'foreigners' in India. Muslim and Christian fundamentalists may identify wholly with …"
"MaNDala III mentions KIkaTa in Bihar, the easternmost location named in the Rigveda. Witzel, naturally, finds such an…"
"All these points are so obvious that anyone who says that Hinduism is as foreign to India as Islam or Christianity, d…"
"Even the strongest advocate of the Aryan invasion theory cannot, in all honesty, point out any specific spot outside …"
"The Hapta Hindu mentioned in the Vendidad is obviously the Saptasindhu (the Punjab region), and the first land, ‘aban…"
"“Did, indeed any ‘Aryans’ ever invade, or even immigrate into India from outside? Shorn of its leftist and anti-Hindu…"
"“The modern Indo-Aryan languages are not descendants of the Rigvedic dialects, but of other dialects which were conte…"
"Quite apart from the Aryan angle, the decipherment of the Indus Script by Dr. Rao is of great significance for Indian…"
"Sanskrit has many words for the horse: aśva, arvant or arvvā, haya, vājin, sapti, turanga, kilvī, pracelaka and gho ṭ…"