"The only true and scientific method according to Comte is therefore the inductive method and science is only such as is based on experiment. Secondly, the aim and apex of science is the new science of the imaginary organism of humanity or of the super-organic being-humanity: this new imaginary science being sociology. From this view of science in general it appeared that all former knowledge was false, and the whole history of humanity's knowledge of itself fell into three, or really two, periods: # The theological and metaphysical periods, lasting from the commencement of the world until Comte # and the present period of true science — positivism — which began with Comte. This was all very nice; there was only one error, namely, that the whole edifice was built on the sand — on the arbitrary assertion that humanity is an organism. That assertion was arbitrary because we have no more right to acknowledge the existence of an organism of humanity not subject to observation than we have to acknowledge the existence of a triune God and similar theological propositions. That assertion was fallacious because to the conception of humanity, that is, of men, the definition of an organism was incorrectly affixed despite the fact that humanity lacks the essential sign of an organism, namely a centre of sensation and consciousness. We only call an elephant or a bacterium an 'organism' because, by analogy we attribute to those beings a similar unification of sensation and of consciousness to that we are conscious of in ourselves; but in human societies and in humanity this essential indication is lacking, and therefore, however many other indications we may detect that are common to humanity and to an organism, in the absence of that essential indication, the acknowledgement of humanity as an organism is incorrect. But despite the arbitrariness and incorrectness of its fundamental basis the positive philosophy was accepted most cordially by the so-called educated world, so important for that world was the justification this philosophy afforded to the existing order of things by regarding the present rule of violence among men as Just. What is remarkable in this connexion is that of Comte's works which consist of two parts — the positive philosophy and the positive politics — the learned world only accepted the first: the part which, on the new experimental basis, offered a justification for the existing evil of human societies; but the second part, dealing with the moral obligations of altruism resulting from acknowledging humanity as an organism, was considered not merely unimportant but even insignificant and unscientific."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Philosophers from FranceCultural criticsSocial criticsSociologists from FranceEconomists from France
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Leo Tolstoy, What then must we do? (1886); as translated by Aylmer Maude.
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Auguste_Comte
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Auguste Comte
1798 – 1857
französischer Mathematiker und Philosoph
32 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Auguste Comte →
Related Quotes
"It was under Catholic Feudalism that they were first united; a union for which their incorporation into the Roman emp…"
"To understand a science it is necessary to know its history."
"The dead govern the living."
"Social positivism only accepts duties, for all and towards all. Its constant social viewpoint cannot include any noti…"
"Men are not allowed to think freely about chemistry and biology: why should they be allowed to think freely about pol…"
"Foreknowledge is power."
"Reorganisation, irrespectively of God or king, by the worship of Humanity, systematically adopted. Man’s only right i…"
"The object of all true Philosophy is to frame a system which shall comprehend human life under every aspect, social a…"
"The first condition of unity is a subjective principle; and this principle in the Positive system is the subordinatio…"
"It lays down, as is generally known, that our speculations upon all subjects whatsoever, pass necessarily through thr…"