"I find from experience both with government agencies and with private business that there are striking differences. One of those differences is that, in government, there is more continuity and definition in the mandate. The limits of action are often clearly defined. in many cases by Congress. No such situation exists in large private business. Dimock says bureaucracies are related, for example, to size. Yet he points out some bearings on bureaucracies of the inadequacies in our federal civil service system and the conflict of loyalties which arises out of it. This, he states, he succeeded in overcoming. I have had contact with several war agencies made up mainly of businessmen. These men rapidly took on bureaucratic characteristics radically different from their own behavior in private life. The only close parallels I find in the areas of private business to the deadening effects of the present civil service are, on the one hand, what one of my old labor leaders used to call the "sonority" system and, on the other, the very real problems faced by management in dealing with labor which arise immediately out of the prolonged governmental support for organized labor-which is in my judgment bad for labor."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Academics from the United StatesEconomists from the United StatesBusiness theorists from the United States
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
p. 176; cited in: Albert Lepawsky (1949), Administration, p. 194-5
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Wallace_Brett_Donham
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Wallace Brett Donham
1919 – 1942
Wallace Brett Donham (1877 – November 29, 1954) was an American organizational theorist, Professor of Business Administration and the second dean of the from 1919-1942. The use of case studies in HBS education was greatly expanded during Donham's time as dean.
16 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Wallace Brett Donham →
Related Quotes
"All these associates were willing to help me in expanding my habit of trying to look all around things before interpr…"
"The problem is one in the general physiology of society. The continuance of life and health for any individual depend…"
"The inability of business and political leadership to rise to new heights [required by the] unprecedented situation, …"
"Everything ahead of us is dangerous. There isn’t a power the President has asked for that isn’t dangerous. But there …"
"In the social sciences there has been a serious gap, except where administration is involved, between the theorist an…"
"At this point water-tight compartments of university specialization and theories founded on the selected isolation of…"
"As a result our graduates leave us without having formed the habit of seeking wide generalizations related to diverse…"
"Dimock makes the generalization that 90 percent of the characteristics of public government executive management are …"
"To me, there are multifarious forces at work in government departments which are different from those in private busi…"
"p. 176; cited in: Albert Lepawsky (1949), Administration, p. 194-5"