"From the facts of nature one can infer further facts of nature, but one cannot with any certainty infer anything beyond nature, not even with any probability. At most, one can say that there are some events one is not able to explain by means of any hitherto known facts; and at such points one may possibly elect to postulate some occult entities or forces, pending further research. Past experience indicates that all such invocations are extremely likely to be dated by a new advance in science. Indeed, even as one writer postulates some unknown entity outside of nature, some scientist elsewhere may be able to dispense with it. Moreover, even if it were permissible to infer something supra-scientific from the facts of nature, it is never really the facts of nature that determine what precisely is invoked at that point, but some preconceived ideas mediated by religion. At the crucial point, natural theology falls back on dogmatic theology. It is the teachings of the theologian’s religion, not the facts of nature, that decide whether, where other explanations fail, he should invoke one god or two, or more; a god of love, a god of wrath, or one of each, or several of each, or one who loves some and hates others, or perhaps a god of perfect love who permits, or insists upon, eternal torment."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Section 25 (pp. 92-93)
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/The_Faith_of_a_Heretic
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
The Faith of a Heretic
137 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by The Faith of a Heretic →
Related Quotes
"What matters in the present context is that no doctrine of immortality or resurrection can solve the problem of suffe…"
"The historically ignorant believe in absolute novelty."
"One’s strategy in trying to defend or to attack the claim that God exists obviously depends on what is meant by “God.…"
"In most of the Hebrew Scriptures it is simply axiomatic that suffering comes from God."
"Nietzsche remarked in The Dawn (¶84) how Christian scholars and preachers had spread “the art of reading badly.”"
"It does not follow that the meaning must be given from above; that life and suffering must come neatly labeled; that …"
"Such pleasant suggestions conflict with the historic evidence."
"The logical enormity of Schweitzer’s argument is obvious. Few men have done more than he to demonstrate the complete …"
"The theism preached from thousands of pulpits and credited by millions of believers is disproved by Auschwitz and a b…"
"Far from being an isolated dictum, the prospect of damnation is one of the central motifs of the Gospels."