"If we assume that the person asking the question is serious, there is an underlying background of purposes and understanding (the 'horizon' as Gadamer calls it) into which the question fits. If a questioner were to ask "Can pigs have wings?" a respondent within the analytic tradition might have difficulty answering, because although the idea is outrageously farfetched, current work in genetic engineering does leave open the logical possibility of creating a beast with the desired characteristics. Admittedly, there might be some refuge in challenging the asker as to whether such a monstrosity would still properly be called a pig,11 thereby invalidating the question. But if the question were asked seriously, neither the logical possibility nor the precise meaning of "pig" would be the issue at hand. The questioner would be asking for some reason in some background of understanding and purpose, and the appropriate answer (just like the appropriate answer to "Is there water in the refrigerator?") would have to be relevant to that background."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Engineers from the United StatesAcademics from the United StatesJews from the United StatesComputer scientists from the United StatesScientists from Maryland
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
11 See, for example Putnam's discussion of natural kinds in "Is semantics possible?" (1970).
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Terry_Winograd
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Terry Winograd
7 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Terry Winograd →
Related Quotes
"The main activity of programming is not the origination of new independent programs, but in the integration, modifica…"
"The techniques of artificial intelligence are to the mind what bureaucracy is to human social interaction."
"Seekers after the glitter of intelligence are misguided in trying to cast it in the base metal of computing. There is…"
"What surprised me, which Google was part of, is that superficial search techniques over large bodies of stuff could g…"
"There is a tendency to throw computers at third world problems, which I think is often a distraction. Putting compute…"
"A reason to have computers understand natural language is that it’s an extremely effective way of communicating. What…"
"For him delicious flavors dwell In books as in old Muscatel."
"And in the evening, everywhere Along the roadside, up and down, I see the golden torches flare Like lighted street-la…"
"Song like a rose should be; Each rhyme a petal sweet; For fragrance, melody, That when her lips repeat The words, her…"
"The hunter catches a dreadful prey, the seaman steers his ship into an unspeakable harbor, the plowman sows and reaps…"