"There are many ways that reviewing can be dishonest. Here is one illustration, drawn from no less a personnage than the self-appointed doyen of the literature dons, Terry Eagleton. A standard rhetorical device in discursive literature has the form “some say X, but I say Y.” The author might not disagree with X, but thinks Y is the more important point. A scurrilous reviewer can systematically misrepresent the author by saying, “the author says X” and omitting the author’s rider “Y”. This is one of Eagleton’s techniques of choice (chapter and verse can be abundantly supplied). Of course, this might not be intentional on Eagleton’s part; he might merely be stupid or lazy. But since it is better to doubt this, we have to conclude instead that he is guilty of wilful misrepresentation. It is alarming to think that such are the ethics of criticism he teaches his students at Manchester University."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Literary criticsPhilosophers from EnglandCatholics from EnglandUniversity of Oxford facultyTrotskyists
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
A. C. Grayling, Life, Sex, and Ideas: The Good Life Without God (2002), , Chapter 55, "Reading and Reviewing"
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Terry_Eagleton
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Terry Eagleton
57 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Terry Eagleton →
Related Quotes
"Postmodernism is among other things a sick joke at the expense of... revolutionary avant-gardism."
"Deconstruction... insists not that truth is illusory but that it is institutional."
"Literature transforms and intensifies ordinary language, deviates systematically from everyday speech. If you approac…"
"If the masses are not thrown a few novels, they may react by throwing up a few barricades."
"All consciousness is consciousness of something: in thinking I am aware that my thought is 'pointing towards' some ob…"
"The present is only understandable through the past, with which it forms a living continuity; and the past is always …"
"Literary texts do not exist on bookshelves: they are processes of signification materialized only in the practice of …"
"Reading is not a straightforward linear movement, a merely cumulative affair: our initial speculations generate a fra…"
"What was needed was a literary theory which, while preserving the formalist bent of New Criticism, its dogged attenti…"
"Chaucer was a class traitor Shakespeare hated the mob Donne sold out a bit later Sidney was a nob."