"‘Equating the Muslim personal law, in its present local state, to the Quran and Hadith, describing it as a wholly revealed or inspired law, and declaring that not an iota of the existing principles can be changed, only exposes the ignorance of Islamic values, Islamic religion and Islamic jurisprudence. Attempting to distort facts about the recent reform of personal law in the Muslim countries cannot do any good. Throwing mud on those who have progressive tendencies and talk of reform of the Muslim personal law, or making contemptuous remarks about their sincerity and wisdom, cannot help either. Instead of trying to conceal the realities, the Muslims must face them. If after having been practised in India in an uncontrolled way for tens of centuries, the Muslim personal law is found being misused and misapplied and consequently lagging behind the social progress in the country, there is nothing in it to be ashamed of. Instead of being stubborn or obstinate about it, the situation has to be duly appreciated, and made good... It is no sensible argument that any reform of the Muslim personal law would amount to interference in religious freedom and affect the cultural identity of Muslims. If the Muslim personal law is codified and reformed—men are restrained from pronouncing a divorce arbitrarily, women’s rights in family life are enlarged, and orphaned grandchildren of a deceased Muslim are allowed to share the latter’s heritage along with other heirs—how is the religious freedom or cultural identity of Muslims going to be affected?... It is irrelevant for cultural identity whether a Muslim can torture his first wife by contracting a bigamous marriage against her wishes and without necessity, or a wife can tease her husband throughout his life by exploiting his inability to pay dower. These and the other drawbacks in the existing personal law cannot be considered essential ingredients of the Muslim culture...’"
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
quoted in Arun Shourie - The World of Fatwas Or The Sharia in Action (2012, Harper Collins)
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Tahir_Mahmood
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Tahir Mahmood
10 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Tahir Mahmood →
Related Quotes
"The way certain chosen passages arbitrarily picked up from the Holy Quran are being used to demonise the Muslim relig…"
"Religious polemics are bitter relics of the past. We cannot afford to revive them in the 21st century India rightly p…"
"The Holy Quran – the same Quran in which ignorant critics find a verse which according to their understanding asks Mu…"
"What is indeed more reassuring and thought-provoking in respect of inter-religious harmony is the fact that numerous …"
"‘The existence of so many schools of Muslim law in India and, more than that, the insistence by the followers of each…"
"‘It is palpably inconceivable that none of these traditional legal principles has lost even an iota of its original r…"
"‘It is unwise for the Muslims of India,’... ‘to shut their eyes to the tremendous progress in the fields of personal …"
"‘To insist that the Muslim personal law prevailing in India should be preserved as it is amounts to insisting on the …"
"‘It is claimed that Islam was the emancipator of women,’.... ‘It liberated Eve from man’s oppression and gave her a l…"
"PHFI is a private society cleverly disguised as a public-private partnership since some of the people in the governin…"