"I was part of the national German committee to plan celebrations for the 2005 Einstein Year. One hundred years after Einstein made his most famous discoveries, the left-leaning government had decided to spend 20 million euros to show its support of science in general and of left-wing cosmopolitan (ahem!) intellectuals in particular. As the only Jew on the committee, my main function would be as what Orthodox Jews call a mashgiach—someone who guarantees that the premises are kosher. There were exhibits, there were banners, there were lectures, and more. What if they made a mistake? I spotted one in an early brochure, where Einstein was described as a "fellow-citizen-of-Jewish-background." Did the committee know, I asked, that Einstein had expressly ridiculed that weird circumlocution? "He just called himself a Jew," I said. "Jews don't consider the word insulting." "Is that so, Frau Neiman?" replied the minister of science. She was flustered. "That’s very helpful, just the sort of thing we need to know." Jew in German has two syllables, not one, and I suppose that buried deep in some dreams are memories of sinister mobs shouting Ju-dah! Ju-dah! Perhaps even for atheists, echoes of Judas Iscariot play a role. Germans use phrases with nine syllables, like fellow-citizen-of-Jewish-extraction or fellow-citizen-of-Jewish-heritage, in order to avoid using the obvious two. The habit is so engrained that despite my objection, the second draft of the brochure used the same phrase. "I know we all have many duties here," I said at the next meeting. "But perhaps it has been forgotten that I mentioned that Einstein didn't like this designation. He made fun of it several times." I was learning to use certain forms of polite circumlocution myself. "Of course," said the minister’s deputy. "We’ll see it gets changed." They never did; too many nightmares worked against them."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Philosophers from the United StatesEssayists from the United StatesJews from the United StatesWomen academics from the United StatesPeople from Atlanta
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
From the introduction. A version of this essay was published as "Working Off the Past, from Atlanta to Berlin", The New York Review of Books (August 29, 2019)
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Susan_Neiman
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Susan Neiman
21 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Susan Neiman →
Related Quotes
"[On members of the Nazi Party] [T]he most shocking, but also important thing, is they were not the uneducated masses.…"
"Whenever you say anything good about East Germany [...] immediately somebody jumps up and says, "My God, you’re a Sta…"
"It took Germans some time to learn this after the second world war, but they finally invented a concept for it: Verga…"
"How do we remember the parts of our histories we'd rather forget? Repression and revision are always options."
"French schoolchildren can be proud to become citizens of the country that gave the world the Declaration of the Right…"
"There's no question that the right-wing campaign to ban from American classrooms anything that might cause discomfort…"
"The picture of modern philosophy as centered in epistemology and driven by the desire to ground our representations i…"
"Like many others, I came to philosophy to study matters of life and death, and was taught that professionalization re…"
"However long Jewish, Christian and Muslim theologians struggle to find multiple meanings in this text, the dominant s…"
"Statues are not about history. We don't memorialize each piece of history. We memorialize things that we want to valu…"