"Here he unwittingly puts his finger on what I believe is the actual source of the near-century of discomfort and disagreement. There is an implicit assumption, shared by almost all physicists, that the scientist must be separated from the science. The usual appeals to measurement with classical outcomes, it seems to me, are unsuccessful attempts to objectify and impersonalize processes in which an individual scientist acts on and is reacted upon by the world. The collapse of the wavefunction after measurement represents nothing more than the updating of that scientist’s expectations, based on his or her experience of the world’s response to the measurement. Weinberg hopes to keep the scientist out of the laws of nature, but our chronic failure to agree on the meaning of quantum mechanics demonstrates the futility of his hope. Nor does Weinberg’s hope make sense to me. Science is a highly developed form of human language. Embedded in books and papers, it is a distillation of the communicated individual experiences of all scientists. Why insist that science should make no reference to the process that has established it? The laws of quantum mechanics are exactly the same for everyone who uses them. In that important sense they are entirely objective. If a scientific law involves both the scientist and the world, it does not mean that science can tell us nothing about people, as Weinberg mysteriously worries, any more than it means that science can tell us nothing about the world."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Activists from the United StatesAtheism activistsAtheists from the United StatesAcademics from the United StatesPhysicists from the United States
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
N. David Mermin, "Can the scientist play a role in the laws of physics?", Physics Today (01 January 2019)
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Steven_Weinberg
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Steven Weinberg
1933 – 2021
US-amerikanischer Physiker und Nobelpreisträger
106 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Steven Weinberg →
Related Quotes
"If you have bought one of those T-shirts with Maxwell's equations on the front, you may have to worry about its going…"
"Religion is an insult to human dignity. With or without it you would have good people doing good things and evil peop…"
"The more the universe seems comprehensible, the more it also seems pointless."
"Either by God you mean something definite or you don't mean something definite. If by God you mean a personality who …"
"So what happens to the effective field theories of electroweak, strong, and gravitational interactions at energies of…"
"... most physicists would probably agree that the place of local fields is nowhere so secure as in the theory of phot…"
"As everyone today knows, in specifying the value of a gauge coupling constant it is necessary to say not only what it…"
"Elementary particles are terribly boring, which is one reason why we're so interested in them."
"Considering the pervasive importance of quantum mechanics in modern physics, it is odd how rarely one hears of effort…"
"One of the great achievements of science has been, if not to make it impossible for intelligent people to be religiou…"