"[Religiologist David] Frankfurter’s central objection is that Kent conflates mythic narratives with historical reality. … Kent’s theory of “deviant scripturalism” posits that fringe groups can use or misuse specific religious texts—particularly those involving incest, sacrifice, or divine violence—to justify abuse. But Frankfurter argues that this approach lacks historical grounding. Kent’s method, he counters, amounts to a kind of speculative anthropology, in which the mere presence of a mythic in scripture is taken as evidence of its enactment in ritual. This is not just a methodological quibble. It strikes at the heart of Kent’s argument. By treating scriptural motifs as behavioral templates, Kent blurs the line between text and practice, belief and action. Frankfurter points out that such motifs are ubiquitous in religious literature, yet rarely—if ever—translated into ritual abuse. Historical data do not support the leap from narrative to crime."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Massimo Introvigne, "A Modern Léo Taxil: Stephen Kent and Satanism. 3. Scholars Strike Back", Bitter Winter (October 3, 2025)
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Stephen_A._Kent
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Stephen A. Kent
4 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Stephen A. Kent →
Related Quotes
"Kent’s critics have long accused him of using anti-cultism as a tool to promote a broader hostility toward religion, …"
"… [In his recent work, Kent] portrays several religions as breeding grounds for mental illness and abuse rather than …"
"Kent’s problem is not that he critiques religion. The problem is how he does it. He constructs a sensational and simp…"
"Mon approche vise a comprendre un phénomène, pas à définir si une secte est "bonne" ou "mauvaise"."
"En 1976-1977, j'ai été actif dans certains mouvements politiques classés très à droite. Je ne dirai pas, comme certai…"
"Je dis parfois à ces interlocuteurs que je ne suis pas insensible à ce qu'ils vivent parce que j'ai eu moi aussi mon …"
"Dès que cela fut connu, en cette folle journée d'octobre 1994, il fallut faire face à un raz-de-marée journalistique …"
"Nous sommes aux antipodes de l'humilité propre aux saints et aux vrais maîtres spirituels. Le Temple Solaire sombre d…"
"His tact and firmness and his Catholic faith were of immense service to all in solving many complicated questions of …"
"First, to put it colloquially, the call for stronger enforcement through order making powers, the ability of the OPC …"