"One of the funniest examples of these kinds of statistics comes from Evolution: Possible or Impossible by James F. Coppedge [who] cites an article by Ulric Jelinek … which claims that the odds are 1 in 10^243 against "two thousand atoms" (the size of one particular protein molecule) ending up in precisely that particular order "by accident." Where did Jelenik get that figure? From Pierre Lecompte du Nouy... who in turn got it from Charles-Eugene Guye, a physicist who died in 1942. Guye had merely calculated the odds of these atoms lining up by accident if "a volume" of atoms the size of the Earth were "shaken at the speed of light." In other words, ignoring all the laws of chemistry, which create preferences for the formation and behavior of molecules, and ignoring that there are millions if not billions of different possible proteins--and of course the result has no bearing on the origin of life, which may have begun from an even simpler protein. This calculation is thus useless for all these reasons, and is typical in that it comes to Coppedge third-hand (and thus to us fourth-hand), and is hugely outdated (it was calculated before 1942, even before the discovery of DNA), and thus fails to account for over half a century of scientific progress."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Richard Carrier, "Bad Science, Worse Philosophy", Addendum B, at The Secular Web (Internet Infidels: 2000)
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Speed_of_light
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Speed of light
44 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Speed of light →
Related Quotes
"You will begin to touch heaven, Jonathan, in the moment that you touch perfect speed. And that isn't flying a thousan…"
"Fermat had recourse to the principle of the economy of nature. Heron and Olympiodorus had pointed out in antiquity th…"
"The speed of light sucks."
"Hubble's law predicts that galaxies beyond ...the Hubble distance, recede faster than the speed of light ...this dist…"
"The radiation of the cosmic microwave background... has a red shift of about 1,000. ...the hot plasma of the early un…"
"A light beam that is farther than the Hubble distance of 14 billion light-years ...cannot keep up with the stretching…"
"When you are next out of doors on a summer night, turn your head towards the zenith. Almost vertically above you will…"
"Another topic deserving discussion is Einstein’s modification of Newton’s law of gravitation. In spite of all the exc…"
"For over 200 years the equations of motion enunciated by Newton were believed to describe nature correctly, and the f…"
"One of the problems has to do with the speed of light and the difficulties involved in trying to exceed it. You can't…"