"However, Seidenberg was told by the Indologists that these Sutras, or any Vedic text for that matter, were definitely written later than 1700 BC. But mathematical data cannot be manipulated just like that, and Seidenberg remained convinced of his case: “Whatever the difficulty there may be [concerning chronology], it is small in comparison with the difficulty of deriving the Vedic ritual application of the theorem from Babylonia. (The reverse derivation is easy)… the application involves geometric algebra, and there is no evidence of geometric algebra from Babylonia. And the geometry of Babylonia is already secondary whereas in India it is primary.” [To satisfy the indologists, he said that the Shulba Sutra had conserved an older tradition, and that it is from this one that the Babylonians had learned their mathematics:] “Hence we do not hesitate to place the Vedic (…) rituals, or more exactly, rituals exactly like them, far back of 1700 BC. (…) elements of geometry found in Egypt and Babylonia stem from a ritual system of the kind described in the Sulvasutras.”"
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Shulba Sutras
6 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Shulba Sutras →
Related Quotes
"Anyway, the damage had been done and the Sulvasutras have never taken the position in the history of mathematics that…"
"In the Shulba Sutra appended to Baudhayana’s Shrauta Sutra, mathematical instructions are given for the construction …"
"The Sulvasutras are a class of works, preserved in various schools, such as those of Baudhayana, Apastamba, and Katya…"
"Neugebauer has shown that these values [of irrational numbers in the Sulvasutras] are identical with those found in c…"
"Yet long before 1937 people had suggested a non-Greek origin to Greek mathematics; and long before 1943 people had po…"
"Put simply, the main insight of the Vaiśeṣika is that consciousness is not to be found as a property that emerges out…"
"Kaṇāda speaks of nitya as a property that does not change or is invariant. From the perspective of physics, the idea …"
"There are nine classes of substances (dravya), some of which are non-atomic, some atomic, and others all-pervasive. T…"
"The intuition behind the theory is that one atom is indicative of solidity and this is the heaviest; the second atom …"
"As I began to study the VS I was astonished by the sophistication of the system. Concluding that Kaṇāda’s work is a m…"