"The charismatic leader says, "I know what is best for the people" (or "we know what is best for the people") and reaps applause. The authoritative teacher says, "There is a book; in it is written what is best for the people; you will follow me and go by that book, even against your will, so that things will be best for the people." The role model says, "Do as I do, because I have the knowledge and personal experience to know what is best for the people." But the facilitator says, "I have come to the conclusion that this is what is best for the people; let's sit down and discuss it, and I will try to convince you." Since this leader says "come let's sit down" and not "run after me," he has no chance of garnering rhythmic applause in the town square. It is difficult to ask people to sit down and think a minute. It is thought to be practically unleaderly. As if a leader, like a gym instructor, must always make people run...The facilitator demands that we be independent, think autonomously, be critical, have an open mind. In other words, he demands that we be not subjects in a more or less enlightened regime, but citizens; this is sometimes a painful process, because knowing the difference between good and evil also means expulsion from the Eden of childhood. But if we do not leave this Garden of Eden, we will never be able to mend or change anything about our reality"
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Jews from IsraelNon-fiction authors from IsraelWomen authors from PolandPoets from IsraelEssayists from Israel
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Imported from EN Wikiquote
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Shulamith_Hareven
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Shulamith Hareven
Shulamith Hareven (Hebrew: ืฉืืืืืช ืืจืืื; pen name, Tal Yaeri; February 14, 1930 โ November 25, 2003) was a Jewish author and essayist who was born in Warsaw, Poland and later lived many years in Israel.
138 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Shulamith Hareven โ
Related Quotes
"The boundaries which will determine our future are not geographic...The true boundary is, rather, the knowledge that โฆ"
"The peace must not be seen as a peace of industrialists and yuppies; it must not be seen as a peace between people inโฆ"
"One essential thing did change: from now on it is not automatically Jew against Arab and Arab against Jew; it is the โฆ"
"To my mind, the whole world is nothing more than an invitation to take part in creation. Literature, at least-or at lโฆ"
"Sara's father, never having met Morality, had perhaps been exempted from it. Even in Jerusalem of the early century, โฆ"
"The sounds of a small city. As small as a man's palm. (chapter 2 p22)"
"Her laugh is like slivers of sunlight. (about Hulda, chapter 3 p40)"
""The first child forces you to define yourself," he said. "When the second comes, you're already defined. Not just asโฆ"
"An ocean of music foams through him in great waves and keeps on going. (about Tony Crowther, chapter 6 p130)"
"The greatest danger to any discipline is the creation of a static model that keeps the same vocabulary for any lengthโฆ"