"In Western societies, we probably know more about the wolf today than we’ve ever known. And there is still so much more to learn. But because we do now have a growing body of scientific evidence about wolf behaviours, that is supporting the conservation of the species as a whole, it is disheartening when National Geographic, a high profile and highly respected organisation, broadcasts a programme that has the potential to undermine a lot of this work by listening to the psycho-babble of someone who appears to be primarily interested in being a self-publicist rather than a wolf advocate. Anyone who has spent any time at all with wild animals will know that a lot of their behaviours are instinctive and innate. Thus self-proclaimed "Wolf Man" Shaun Ellis’s attempts at teaching wolves how to howl and hunt gives one the impression of an arrogant and colonial attitude that really ought to have been left behind in the enlightened times we now live in in wildlife conservation circles. Furthermore, to try and assert that you are accepted as a "wolf" in the pack is not just laughable, but also extremely dangerous, not just for the person making this assertion, but for the wolves too. In the programme, Ellis demonstrated that he was alpha male in his "pack", and indeed the wolves accepted him as being dominant. The end sequence, however, showed Ellis having been demoted to omega status. There are two issues here. One is that broadcasting this kind of interaction and behaviour with wolves gives totally the wrong impression. It is going down the same route as the macho-driven pursuits of the seemingly burgeoning number of TV presenters who think it is acceptable to drag what are perceived to be scary and highly dangerous creatures from their habitats, and wrestle with them and dominate them. Quite how this can be called conservation, I’m not entirely sure, and it certainly doesn’t contribute anything to our knowledge of these creatures. The other issue is that there is a very real risk that one or several of the wolves within the pack could turn on Ellis, and badly injure him. We may still have a lot to learn about wolves, but one thing we do know is that you cannot generalise about wolf behaviour. The complexities involved make this virtually impossible. An attack on Ellis would potentially undo decades of work undertaken by thousands of people who work with and for wolves. The wolves themselves would very likely have to be destroyed, and through one man’s misguided or foolish attempts at demonstrating the dynamics of wolf behaviour in this way, he would simply be achieving quite the opposite."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Denise Taylor (summer 2007), "Humans are not wolves!", WolfPrint, issue 31
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Shaun_Ellis
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Shaun Ellis
21 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Shaun Ellis →
Related Quotes
"My perception of wolves was much the same as any other kid. I was brought up to fear them. But it was through the fox…"
"It was really evident that what we were learning from a scientific point of view from wolves wasn't very much. The Na…"
"They have called me bizarre, neurotic or silly, and said that what I am doing is pointless. "Animals don't need a hum…"
"My ultimate ambition is to introduce a captive pack of wolves into the wild and live with them."
"Wolves don't suffer things like guilt or remorse. They don't have any problems with the amount of discipline that the…"
"My obsession with wolves hadn't helped past relationships. I had split up with Jan, the mother of my four children, a…"
"I had always aimed to bridge the gap between humans and wolves but being able to speak for the wolf is pointless unle…"
"I have to come to terms with the fact that I am not good at human relationships. I've known some wonderful women and …"
"Native Americans would say that [the sight of a fox killed in a trap] was the moment when my fate was sealed. They sa…"
"No one would listen to me when I tried to protest that foxhunting was cruel. And as a young boy it was hard to argue …"