"The more I learned about this Indian "secularism", the more it became clear to me that it was often the very opposite of what we in the West in genuinely secular states call "secularism". Indeed, over the years I have had many a good laugh at the pompous moralism and blatant dishonesty of India's so-called secularists. Their specialty is to justify double standards, e.g. why mentioning murdered Kashmiri Pandits is “communal hate-mongering” while the endless litany about murdered Gujarati Muslims is “secular consciousness-raising”. Sometimes they merely stonewall inconvenient information, such as when they tried to deny and suppress the historical data about the forcible replacement of a Rama temple in Ayodhya by a mosque: given the strength of the evidence, all they could do was to drown out any serious debate with screams and swearwords. But often they do bring out their specific talents at sophistry, such as when they argue that a Common Civil Code, a defining element of all secular states, is a Hindu communalist notion, while the preservation of the divinely-revealed Shari’a for the Muslims is secular. That’s when they are at their best."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Koenraad Elst,
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Secularism_in_India
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Secularism in India
62 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Secularism in India →
Related Quotes
"I believe that the word secular is the biggest lie since Independence. Those that have given birth to this lie and th…"
"Secular, as I understand, means that religion should not play any role in governance. If it’s true, then why were you…"
"The secular state assumes that the Semitic religions and the Hindu traditions are instances of the same kind."
"“When Indian intellectuals use existing theories about religion and its history – for example, to analyse ‘Hindu-Musl…"
"‘Christianity spreads in two ways,’ an Indian historian has written: ‘through conversion and through secularisation.’"
"No matter how much tyranny, how much injustice is heaped on Hindus anywhere in the world, the State of India is not b…"
"Since ‘Enlightenment Secularism’, with its core principle of separation, founded on the Protestant conception of reli…"
"The recent import of secularism from the West is based on substituting 'religion' for 'dharma' and adopting Western s…"
"The general enthusiasm for "secularism" in itself should indicate that the meaning of the term has undergone a drasti…"
"As far as I know, Nehru never defined secularism in its proper European and historical context."