"In this context, it is notable that so many US troops are willing to state they would openly disobey orders such as detaining people inhumanely, starving civilians or shooting civilians. And research shows if even a minority is willing to stand up, it can matter. Criminologist Eva Whitehead researched conscientious disobedience during the Vietnam War and at the East German border during the Cold War: her work found that when some troops disobeyed, it was easier for others to follow suit. Opposition to following unlawful orders is prevalent among U.S. troops. The question is whether it will make a difference when it counts. Uniformed personnel understand the concept of an order that is manifestly unlawful, and their own responsibility to disobey such an order. This won't entirely prevent harm, as some of those soldiers may still buckle under the weight of military hierarchy in a high-stress situation. But the willingness of so many service members to recognize unlawful orders, and their duty to disobey, highlights the moral agency of individuals and the enduring power of international legal standards, even in difficult and unprecedented times."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Charli Carpenter, professor of political science and legal studies at University of Massachusetts-Amherst, Troops Are Obligated to Disobey Unlawful Orders. Would They?", World Politics Review, 26 August 2025
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Second_presidency_of_Donald_Trump
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Second presidency of Donald Trump
287 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Second presidency of Donald Trump →
Related Quotes
"If Iran doesn't FULLY OPEN, WITHOUT THREAT, the Strait of Hormuz, within 48 HOURS from this exact point in time, the …"
"Immediately after the targeting of power plants and infrastructure in our country, vital infrastructure and energy an…"
"When it comes to dealing with the Americans, you have to pick and choose who you deal with and at which level. Luckil…"
"Robert Mueller just died. Good, I’m glad he’s dead. He can no longer hurt innocent people!"
"We must see it as an ally, not an asset, and focus on continued partnership rather than possession."
"Roe labels the issue an “impossible situation” since the federal Head Start Act contains many of the words that progr…"
"Arctic security remains a key priority for Europe and it is critical for international and transatlantic security. NA…"
"This is not more complicated than the fact that Trump wants a giant island with his name on it. He wouldn’t think twi…"
"Minneapolis Mayor Jacob Frey, a Democrat, pointed to bystander video he said directly contradicted the federal govern…"
"BASED ON THE TENOR AND TONE OF THESE IN DEPTH, DETAILED, AND CONSTRUCTIVE CONVERSATIONS, WITCH WILL CONTINUE THROUGHO…"