"The community holds the crucial responsibility to resist overreaction to difference, and to offer alternatives of understanding and complexity. We have to help each other illuminate and counter the role of overstating harm instead of using it to justify cruelty. I suggest that we have a better chance at interrupting unnecessary pain if we articulate our shared responsibility in creating alternatives. Looking for methods of collective problem-solving make these destructive, tragic leaps more difficult to accomplish. People who are being punished for doing nothing, for having normative conflict, or for resisting unjustified situations, need the help of other people. While there are many excuses for not intervening in unjust punishment, that intervention is, nonetheless, essential. Without the intervention that most people are afraid to commit to, this escalation cannot be interrupted. In other words, because we won’t change our stories to integrate other people’s known reasons and illuminate their unknown ones, we cannot resolve Conflict in a way that is productive, equitable, and fair. This is why we (individuals, couples, cliques, families, communities, nations, peoples) often pretend, believe, or claim that Conflict is, instead, Abuse and therefore deserves punishment. That the mere fact of the other person’s difference is misrepresented as an assault that then justifies our cruelty and relinquishes our responsibility to change. Consequently, resistance to that false charge of Abuse is then positioned as further justification of even more cruelty masquerading as “punishment,” through the illogic at base of refusing accountability and repair."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
LGBT peopleLGBT rights activistsWomen academics from the United StatesWomen activists from the United StatesActivists from New York City
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Imported from EN Wikiquote
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Sarah_Schulman
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Sarah Schulman
98 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Sarah Schulman →
Related Quotes
"The police are often the source of violence, especially in the lives of women, people of color, trans women, sex work…"
"In the embodiment of the good group, through the therapist, a person can be helped to understand their own motivation…"
"There are options, and even though anxiety may make the reality of choices elusive, they still exist. Recognize the e…"
"Resisting unjustified punishment is not Abuse. And people who are being asked to stand by and passively allow shunnin…"
"What was even more distracting and confusing was that the job of punishing the expressions of patriarchy, racism, and…"
"Anxiety is best addressed by support and love in trying to understand those reasons, not the false “loyalty” of aggre…"
"We should not isolate, denounce, and punish people for being human."
"When anxiety is at the wheel, we tragically project, blame, and then separate. We flee reality, which is the fact of …"
"Truths can be multiple and are revealed by the order of events. [...] Each moment is a consequence of the previous mo…"
"We have learned over and over again, through the almost mechanistic co-optation of a wide range of radical movements …"