"Freeman and Macaulay are alike in the high value they set upon parliamentary institutions. On the other hand, when Macaulay wants to make you understand a thing, he compares it with that which existed in his own day. The standard of the present is always with him. Freeman traces it to its origin, and testifies to its growth. The strength of this mode of proceeding in an historian is obvious. Its weakness is that it does not help him to appreciate statesmanship looking forward and trying to find a solution of difficult problems. Freeman's attitude is that of the people who cried out for the good laws of King Edward, trying to revive the past."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Letter to James Bryce, quoted in James Bryce, Studies in Contemporary Biography (1903), p. 274
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Samuel_Rawson_Gardiner
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Samuel Rawson Gardiner
Samuel Rawson Gardiner (4 March 1829 – 24 February 1902) was an English historian who specialized in 17th-century English history as a prominent foundational historian of the Puritan revolution and the English Civil War.
20 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Samuel Rawson Gardiner →
Related Quotes
"Ranke is cold and unenthusiastic; and, in judging individuals, it is well to be cold and unenthusiastic. But is there…"
"England, it has been said by one who, in our own days, has exhibited the old Puritan virtues to a world which had wel…"
"It has not, I hope, been for nothing that many years ago, as a young and unknown writer, I deliberately refrained fro…"
"To the historian no more interesting period can be found than one in which men of virtue and ability strove with one …"
"Whatever the future may have in reserve, this present work has constantly reminded me by how deep a gulf we are separ…"
"Certainly the politics of the seventeenth century, when studied for the mere sake of understanding them, assume a ver…"
"The statesman uses his imagination to predict the result of changes to be produced in the actually existing state of …"
"The more of a student he is—and no one can be a historian without being a very devoted student—the more he is removed…"
"Unless the historian can feel an affectionate as well as an intelligent interest in the personages with whom he deals…"
"What may be fairly demanded alike of Cromwell's admirers and of his critics is that they shall fix their eyes upon hi…"