"The evidence concerning horses remains nonetheless the weakest point in the case for an Indian Urheimat. While the evidence is arguably not such that it proves the Harappan culture’s unfamiliarity with horses, it cannot be claimed to prove the identity of Vedic and Harappan culture either, the way the abundance of horse remains in Ukraine is used to prove the IE character of the settlements there. At this point, the centre-piece of the anti-AIT plea is an explainable paucity of the evidence material, so that everything remains possible.... The non-invasionists should recognize the merits in the invasionist skepticism of the horse evidence found in the Harappan cities. It is one thing for Prof. B.B. Lal (one of those healthy doubters who only came to dismiss the “myth of the Aryan invasion” gradually) to cite recent finds of horse bones as proving that “the horse was duly known to the Harappans” and to quote archaeozoologist Prof. Sandor Bokonyi as confirming that the horses found in Surkotada were indeed horses (which some had refused to believe due to their AIT bias), and that “the domestic nature of the Surkotada horses is undoubtful”. It is another to deduce that the horse was simply part of Harappan life rather than an exotic curiosity; AIT defenders have a point when they maintain that the horse was not part of the Harappan lifestyle the way it was in the Kurgan culture. More work is to be done, both in digging and incorrectly interpreting the data."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Sandor Bokonyi quoted in Elst, Koenraad (1999). Update on the Aryan invasion debate New Delhi: Aditya Prakashan. quoting Sandor Bokonyi
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/S%C3%A1ndor_B%C3%B6k%C3%B6nyi
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Sándor Bökönyi
5 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Sándor Bökönyi →
Related Quotes
"It is well known that wild horses did not exist in India in post-Pleistocene times, in the time of horse domesticatio…"
"Thus, the precise identification of equid remains in Surkotada has been conducted by Hungarian expert Prof. Sandor Bo…"
"Through a thorough study of the equid remains of the protohistoric settlement of Surkotada, Kutch, excavated under th…"
"The situation took a new turn, somewhat melodramatically, a few years ago. The material involved had been excavated i…"
"Kuiper [...] clearly puts it [the word for wheat] in the group of foreign words adopted before the Aryans reached Ind…"
"Pāṇini, ArthŚā, Bṛsam and Vṛkṣ(s) define the word [for wheat] as a type of grain distinct from barley and rice […] Ad…"
"An intriguing point emerges from the find of the term Pippali in the list of agricultural terms in the Saunakiya Atha…"
"O. Szemerényi admits that reconstructions are used to facilitate comparisons, using one word instead of many IE varia…"
"Hermann goes even further: complete forms (e.g. *deiwos) cannot be reconstructed at all, only single sounds, and even…"
"Assyrian sources preserved the Lullubean word kiurum ‘god’ which can be regarded as an adoption of PII *kura- (cf. OI…"