"In addition to the lack of a factual record, the oral arguments were burdened by jurisdictional and procedural issues that consumed a considerable amount of time, leaving little time to focus on the substantive medical, historical, and constitutional questions. The first twenty minutes of Weddingtonâs first argument in Roe in December 1971 was spent on procedure and jurisdiction, an much of the last ten minutes as well. The Court asked questions such as who brought the suit, whether they could sue, whether these was any real controversy between Jane Roe and the public officials named as defendants, whether the Court should even hear the appeal, whether the parties should have gone to the federal appeals court first, whether the case was moot, whether an injunction was appropriate. A substantial part of the discussion by Jay Floyd, the attorney for Texas in the first Roe argument, was also spent on procedure and jurisdiction. In the first Doe argument, Margie Pitts Hames addressed some questions on jurisdiction and procedure, and her final question was on jurisdiction Dorothy Beasley also addressed such questions. Again, the amount of time spent on these procedural and jurisdictional questions lends considerable credence to Justice Blackmunâs story that Justice Stewart urged the subcommittee of Justices to hear Roe and Doe under the âmisapprehensionâ that they involved ânothing more than an application of Younger v. Harris.â Indeed, the subcommittee could have been easily misled by the first papers filed in the Supreme Court by Roy Lucas and Sarah Weddington on October 6, 1970, asking the Justices to hear the case. The papers (called a âJurisdictional Statement) consisted of thirty-three pages and presented only two âQuestionsâ for the Justices to address, relating to the propriety of an injunction by the federal court and whether the married couple in the case (not Jan Roe) had âstandingâ to sue-on other words, procedural issues."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
p.98
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Roe_v._Wade
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Roe v. Wade
Roe v. Wade, 410 U.S. 113 (1973), was a landmark decision of the U.S. Supreme Court in which the Court ruled that the
1424 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Roe v. Wade â
Related Quotes
"Harry Blackmun questioned Weddington again on the issue of fetal personhood, as did Potter Stewart. They wanted her tâŠ"
"In 1938, seven Justices heard a constitutional challenge to a federal ban on shipping adulterated milk in interstate âŠ"
"The Court has simultaneously transformed judicially created rights like the right to abortion into preferred constituâŠ"
"Beyond these paltry authorities, the Court adds only the argument that we should not âencourage a kitchen-sink approaâŠ"
"JUSTICE BREYER, with whom JUSTICE SOTOMAYOR and JUSTICE KAGAN join, dissenting. The procedural posture of this case lâŠ"
"JUSTICE SOTOMAYOR, with whom JUSTICE BREYER and JUSTICE KAGAN join, dissenting. The Courtâs order is stunning. PresenâŠ"
"By the time that Michael Taylor sent out his communiquĂ©, pro-life lawyers had been preparing legal arguments in Roe aâŠ"
"Lawyers for the states of both Georgia and Texas argued that abortion restrictions were appropriate because the stateâŠ"
"Pro-life lawyers had complained before about the poor quality of state attorneyâs attempts to defend restrictive aborâŠ"
"Ellen McCormackâs Long Island-based organization, Women for the Unborn, which now had 2,000 members, submitted a brieâŠ"