"[T]he demonization of Mahmud and the portrayal of his raid on Somnath as an assault on Indian religion by Muslim invaders dates only from the early 1840s. In 1842 the suffered the annihilation of an entire army of some 16,000 in the (1839-42). Seeking to regain face among their Hindu subjects after this humiliating defeat, the British contrived a bit of self-serving fiction, namely that Mahmud, after sacking the temple of Somnath, carried off a pair of the temple's gates on his way back to Afghanistan. By 'discovering' these fictitious gates in Mahmud's former capital of Ghazni, and by 'restoring' them to their rightful owners in India, British officials hoped to be admired for heroically rectifying what they construed as a heinous wrong that had caused centuries of distress among India's Hindus. Though intended to win the latters' gratitude while distracting all Indians from Britain's catastrophic defeat just beyond the Khyber, this bit of colonial mischief has stoked Hindus' ill-feeling toward Muslims ever since. From this point on, Mahmud's 1025 sacking of Somnath acquired a distinct notoriety, especially in the early twentieth century when nationalist leaders drew on history to identify clear-cut heroes and villains for the purpose of mobilizing political mass movements. By contrast, Rajendra Chola's raid on Bengal remained largely forgotten outside the Chola country."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Academics from the United StatesNon-fiction authors from the United StatesHistorians from the United StatesPeople from MichiganIndologists
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
India in the Persianate Age, 1000–1765 (2019)
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Richard_M._Eaton
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Richard M. Eaton
22 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Richard M. Eaton →
Related Quotes
"One intriguing thing about Eaton is that his own research of the medieval literatures on Indian Sufis for his Ph.D. t…"
"Regardless of this change in emphasis, it is important to note that not all Western Sufi scholarship of the last half…"
"According to the cover text on his book, Eaton is professor of History at the University of Arizona and “a leading hi…"
"One Western author who has become very popular among India's history-rewriters is the American scholar Prof. Richard …"
"The notion that Babur’s officer destroyed a temple dedicated to Rama’s birthplace at Ayodhya and then got the emperor…"
"When Firuz Tughluq invaded Orissa in 1359 and learned that the region's most important temple was that of Jagannath l…"
"An inscription dated 1455, found over the doorway of a tomb-shrine in Dhar, Madhya Pradesh [mentions] the destruction…"
"One often hears that between the thirteenth and eighteenth centuries, Indo-Muslim states, driven by a Judeo-Islamic “…"
"Before marching to confront Shivaji himself, however, the Bijapur general [Afzal Khan] first proceeded to Tuljapur an…"
"Much of the contemporary evidence on temple desecration cited by Hindu nationalists is found in Persian materials tra…"