"Most environmental dilemmas have to do with limits (usually limits to either resources or to waste sinks). And most environmental solutions have to do with reining in our wants and ambitions in some way. Cleverness may help at the margins—as when chemists identify a relatively harmless substance that can substitute for a toxic one. But without self-limits on population and consumption, no amount of cleverness can halt humanity’s accelerating march toward collapse. Economist William Stanley Jevons got an inkling of this stark reality in 1865, when he published his observation that making coal usage more efficient led to increased coal mining (and depletion), not conservation. Too often, we outsmart ourselves by thinking we’re doing something to save resources and reduce pollution, when in fact we’re just paving the way for more of the same. Another intelligence-resistant problem is deciding what’s a good life or a good death. These are arguably the most important personal questions with which any of us will ever grapple, but intelligence doesn’t always help with answers. It’s true that smart people sometimes avoid a lot of problems that plague less-smart people (such as falling prey to obvious scams and rip-offs). But they just as often end up burdening themselves and others around them with even bigger problems brought on by the unforeseen consequences of their own cleverness—as when a smart investor or inventor accumulates a huge fortune, over which their heirs fight bitterly, to the point that family dynamics are poisoned for generations to come. Finally, there is the uber-problem that should be at the top of all our minds—the long-term survival of humanity. We naturally want our species to stick around. And we like to think that our intelligence improves our prospects in that regard. But, so far, the evidence points in the opposite direction."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Activists from the United StatesNon-fiction authors from the United StatesEducators from the United StatesEnvironmentalists from the United StatesJournalists from Missouri
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Ibid.
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Richard_Heinberg
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Richard Heinberg
22 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Richard Heinberg →
Related Quotes
"Our core ecological problem is not climate change. It is overshoot, of which global warming is a symptom. Overshoot i…"
"Using science, technology, and cheap energy, we expanded farmlands, chain-sawed forests, exploited fisheries, mined m…"
"During the last 200 years, per capita energy usage grew eight-fold, while human population expanded at about the same…"
"Prior to the widespread use of coal, oil, and natural gas, agrarian societies saw cyclical periods of rise and fall. …"
"Fossil fuels enabled a dramatic expansion of energy usable by humanity, in turn enabling unprecedented growth in huma…"
"Global human population has doubled three times in the past 200 years, surging from 1 billion in 1820 to 2 billion in…"
"Climate change is a wicked problem… [and] there is no way to solve it without sacrificing something that society curr…"
"Limits exist everywhere in nature. Physics, chemistry, biology, geology, astronomy—pick your field, dig into the lite…"
"Agriculture enabled population growth and social complexity, but it gradually robbed soils of nutrients. Sailing ship…"
"If we do nothing, we still get to a post-carbon future, but it will be bleak. However, if we plan the transition, we …"