"This momentous finding of nonlocality has, in common with that of Einstein concerning time, the additional feature that it disproves the validity, not of a "view of the World", but of a deeply ingrained concept. And this brings me to the second reason. It is that this disproof of a deeply ingrained concept pointed in fact in a direction quite consonant with my own line of thought. In a way, it brings us back to Descartes, for, as we all know, Descartes was the first scientist who dared to question our common views, including even all the notions that had always seemed so primitive and obvious that thinkers, scientists and so on never hesitated in making use of them. He found out that, at the start, he could doubt of everything but his own thinking, and in this, according to Hegel, he was a hero. Unfortunately he then constructed a grand metaphysical argument that led him to the view that, after all, since God is not a liar, the "obvious" realistic concepts must apply. He thereby founded mechanicism, which is the theory that, apart from thought, everything has to be described by the exclusive means of familiar concepts. We know, of course, how deficient such a view is. But I think Descartes' really significant contribution on these matters is not mechanicism. It is what I just said. In other words, it is the realization that a sharp distinction has to be made between rationality on the one hand and the use of seemingly obvious concepts on the other hand. And that therefore, if you are a rational person you cannot demand that science should be based exclusively on seemingly obvious concepts without first logically justifying this demand. This Descartes tried to do but, since his argument based on God not being a liar is now considered as not convincing enough, we are not bound to his conclusion. Indeed, I consider that we are not even bound to the idea that physics should be expressed in an ontological language, which was more or less Einstein's view. The older Einstein seems to have considered that Reality, and even physical objects in the plural, can be described as they really are, if not by familiar concepts, at least by unfamiliar ones, such as those borrowed from mathematics. I do not think this is necessarily true. I consider that mere predictive rules, such as the Born rule in quantum mechanics, count as fully fledged explanations, or, more precisely, as constituting, when all taken together, a first step in an explanation, the second step being the philosophical idea that these predictive rules dimly reflect some existing, largely hidden structures of Mind-Independent Reality. Of course, these speculations of mine go much further than nonlocality. But you understand that they receive some support from it."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Natural philosophersCatholics from FrancePhilosophers from FranceMathematicians from FrancePhysicists from France
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Bernard d'Espagnat, "My Interaction with John Bell", in Quantum [Un]speakables (2002) edited by R.A. Bertimann, A. Zeilinger
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Ren%C3%A9_Descartes
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
René Descartes
107 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by René Descartes →
Related Quotes
"It appears then that the distance between one thing and another does not depend on any material thing between them, a…"
"What I have given in the second book on the nature and properties of curved lines, and the method of examining them, …"
"No more useful inquiry can be proposed than that which seeks to determine the nature and the scope of human knowledge…"
"Mr. Clerselier has written me that you are expecting from him my Meditations... in order to present them to the queen…"
"Mais apud me omnia fiunt Mathematicè in Natura"
"No doubt you know that Galileo had been convicted not long ago by the Inquisition, and that his opinion on the moveme…"
"M. Desargues puts me under obligations on account of the pains that it has pleased him to have in me, in that he show…"
"Je pense, donc je suis."
"Le bon sens est la chose du monde la mieux partagée : car chacun pense en être si bien pourvu, que ceux même qui sont…"
"Me tenant comme je suis, un pied dans un pays et l'autre en un autre, je trouve ma condition très heureuse, en ce qu'…"