"That I be the better and the clearer understood of the lay people in some words to be after spoken in this present book, I set now before to them this doctrine taken shortly out of the faculty of logic. An argument, if he be full and formal, which is cleped a syllogism, is made of two propositions, driving out of them, and by strength of them, the third proposition. Of the which three propositions the two first be cleped premisses, and the third following out of them is cleped the conclusion of them. And the first of those two premisses is cleped the first premiss, and the second of them is cleped the second premiss. And each such argument is of this kind, that if the both premisses be true the conclusion concluded out, and by them, is also true; and but if evereither of those premisses be true, the conclusion is not true. Ensample thereof is this: “Each man is at Rome, the Pope is a man, eke the Pope is at Rome.” So here be set forth two propositions, which be these: “Each man is at Rome,” and “The Pope is a man”; and these be the two premisses in this argument, and they drive out the third proposition, which is this: “The Pope is at Rome,” and it is the conclusion of the two premisses. Wherefore, certes, if any man can be sicker for any time that these two premisses be true, he may be sicker that the conclusion is true, though all the angels in heaven would say, and hold that, thilk conclusion were not true. And this is a general rule in every good and formal and full argument, that if his premisses be known for true the conclusion ought be avowed for true, whatever creature will say the contrary.What properties and conditions be required to an argument, that he be full and formal and good, is taught in logic by full, fair, and sure rules, and may not be taught of me here in this present book. But would God it were learned of all the common people in their mother’s language, for then they should thereby be put from much rudeness and boisterousness which they have now in reasoning; and then they should soon know and perceive when a skile and an argument bindeth and when he not bindeth, that is to say, when he concludeth and proveth his conclusion, and when he not so doeth; and then they should keep themselves the better from falling into errors, and they might the sooner come out of errors by hearing of arguments made to them, if they into any errors were fallen; and then they should not be so blunt and so rude and informal and boisterous in reasoning, and that both in their arguing and in their answering, as they now be; and then should they not be so obstinate against clerks and against their prelates, as some of them now be, for default of perceiving when an argument proceedeth into his conclusion of needs, and when he not so doeth, but seemeth only so do. And much good would come forth if a short compendious logic were devised for all the common people in their mother’s language; and, certes, to men of court, learning the king’s law of England in these days, thilk now said short compendious logic were full precious. Into whose making, if God will grant leave and leisure, I purpose sometime after mine other business for to essay."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
The Uses of Logic. From Repressour, Part I
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Reginald_Pecock
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Reginald Pecock
(or Peacock; c. 1395 – c. 1461) was a Welsh prelate, scholastic, and writer.
5 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Reginald Pecock →
Related Quotes
"Of which first principal conclusion thus proved followeth further this corollary, that whenever and wherever in Holy …"
"Even as grammar and divinity be two diverse faculties and cunnings, and therefore be unmeddled, and each of them hath…"
"Peradventure they will say thus: Many hundreds of men clepe this image the Trinity, and they clepe this image Christ,…"
"For to turn now again into the matter of religious; though it be sufficiently now before answered to the second seemi…"
"I want to keep on working for the unity of my country. I want to spend my life for lasting peace, peace which has bee…"
"We want to work on evangelization and human development in a difficult are of our country. We are counting on support…"
"The formation of men, in addition to the theological and moral part, includes a so-called "civil" part (for example o…"
"The twentieth century had conclusively settled the question of how a society should be organised: liberal democracy, …"
"For James, there was no sense that expanding Tesco’s sales onto the web was what the human race urgently needed. It d…"
"It was insane that you had to pretend to be interested in your job and use these lame phrases like “pinging things ov…"