"Diverting attention from the way in which certain beliefs, desires, attitudes, or values are the result of particular power relations, then, can be a sophisticated way of contributing to the maintenance of an ideology, and one that will be relatively immune to normal forms of empirical refutation. If I claim (falsely) that all human societies, or all human societies at a certain level of economic development, have a free market in health services, that is a claim that can be demonstrated to be false. On the other hand, if I focus your attention in a very intense way on the various different tariffs and pricing schema that doctors or hospitals or drug companies impose for their products and services, and if I become morally outraged by “excessive” costs some drug companies charge, discussing at great length the relative rates of profit in different sectors of the economy, and pressing the moral claims of patients, it is not at all obvious that anything I say may be straightforwardly “false”; after all, who knows what “excessive” means? However, by proceeding in this way I might well focus your attention on narrow issues of “just” pricing, turning it away from more pressing issues about the acceptance in some societies of the very existence of a free market for drugs and medical services. One can even argue that the more outraged I become about the excessive price, the more I obscure the underlying issue. One way, then, in which a political philosophy can be ideological is by presenting a relatively marginal issue as if it were central and essential."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Academics from the United StatesPhilosophers from the United StatesNon-fiction authors from the United StatesEducators from the United StatesPeople from Indiana
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
p. 54.
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Raymond_Geuss
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Raymond Geuss
39 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Raymond Geuss →
Related Quotes
"One of Nietzsche’s most important legacies to us … is his claim that it is desirable and possible to dismantle the Pl…"
"Nietzsche seems sometimes to replace the “transcendence” which stands at the center of traditional accounts—the exist…"
"The idea that all problems either have a solution or can be shown to be pseudo-problems is not one I share."
"The notion of being an “enlightened” person does not reduce simply to that of being a person who has highly developed…"
"The Kantian philosophy is no more than at best a half-secularized version of such a theocratic ethics, with “Reason” …"
"The pure normative standpoint that Kant’s ethics tries to occupy, a standpoint in which we consider only the normativ…"
"The point of one of Rawls’] main constructions—the introduction of the “veil of ignorance”—is precisely to exclude fr…"
"The actual effect of Rawls’s theory is to undercut theoretically any straightforward appeal to egalitarianism. Egalit…"
"In its origin, liberalism had no ambition to be universal either in the sense of claiming to be valid for everyone an…"
"Either there is or there is not a mechanism for enforcing human rights. If there is not, it would seem that calling t…"