"The same pattern was repeated in the case of the Hindi translation of Ram Swarup's Understanding Islam Through Hadis. ... Radiance, a Weekly published by the Jamaat-e-Islami from Delhi, had raised hell in its issue of 17-23 June, 1990. "Most portions of the book are concoctions and distortions as well as defamatory and derogatory to the Holy Prophet", it wrote. It went on to quote passages from the translation without informing the readers that all of them are found in the orthodox collections of Hadis as well as the pious biographies of the Prophet! It depended on the ignorance of the common Muslim and ascribed those passages to the writer, Ram Swarup! ... But what happened on 27th November 1990 was the most surprising event in the history of this case. A notification of the Delhi Administration announced that the Hindi translation, Hadîs ke Mâdhyama se Islâm kâ Addhyana had been banned and all its copies stood confiscated as soon as published. There was not the hint of a reference that the same Administration had screened the book not once but twice, over a period of three years, cleared it as unobjectionable, and got dismissed the case registered against the publisher and the printer. Come March 1991 and the English original of the book was also banned by the same Administration, without taking into account the fact that this book had been in print and circulation in India for eight years and that the Administration itself had found it unobjectionable after having scrutinized it for months soon after it was published. Strange are the ways of Secularism in India!"
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Goel, Sita Ram (editor) (1998). Freedom of expression: Secular theocracy versus liberal democracy. Ch. 6
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Ram_Swarup
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Ram Swarup
139 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Ram Swarup →
Related Quotes
"One of the most important thought leaders of the Hindu revivalist movement..."
"The importance of Sitaram Goel's and Ram Swarup's work can hardly be over-estimated. There is no doubt that future te…"
"I read with great interest Sri Rain Swarup’s scholarly paper on the intimate connection, amounting almost to identity…"
"It is indeed a strange sect of Islam which claims for itself a founder other than Muhammad and a scripture other than…"
"In 1982, Ram Swarup (1920–1998) established Voice of India, a publishing house that over the next decades published a…"
"Gandhi can be credited with having established and/​or popularized many of the basic arguments against conversion to …"
"What an irony it is. “These books are sacred’—that is the refrain about the Quran and the Hadis compilations. Until y…"
"A representative of India's rishi tradition in the modern age."
"To early European writers, it did not occur to regard Sikhism as different from Hinduism, an observation which agreed…"
"Ram Swarup and Sita Ram Goel were witnesses to the untiring aggression against Hinduism by Christian missionaries, th…"