"The question of whether an ideal has frequently, or ever, been acted upon by men is totally irrelevant. The only relevant question is whether a proposed ideal is one which ought to be acted upon, one which legitimately claims a place in our souls, whether or not we do in fact admit it into our souls and try to live up to it. Justice is not metamorphosed into injustice because there are men who habitually act unjustly. A moral claim, if authentic, does not lapse merely because it is denied, however widely and flagrantly. On the contrary, the very nature of a value implies the possibility that men may fail to comply with it, since a ‘value’ which had legitimacy only if men accepted it but was automatically nullified whenever rejected it could not properly be said to constitute a value at all, that is, something which distinctively seeks to guide and direct our motives and conduct and not just passively reflect what we are already doing or have decided to do. The nature of values is to command or entreat us, to alter and redress our character, not just superfluously to describe it as it already anyway is."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
pp. 19-20.
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/R._W._K._Paterson
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
R. W. K. Paterson
71 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by R. W. K. Paterson →
Related Quotes
"Far from settling his interests on a single, fixed and final object, the nihilistic egoist preserves himself in a con…"
"A world in to whose settled meaning he [the egoist] had committed himself would be a world to which he had alienated …"
"Optimism draws its strength from what it perceives as the underlying themes of human life rather than from the incide…"
"On the one hand, the existentialist seeks to remain true to his original vision of the meaninglessness and futility o…"
"The refusal to make the truth of nihilism one’s own and build one’s life entirely within its shadow is indeed a refus…"
"As proprietor of his beliefs, the egoist never allows them to grow into ‘fixed ideas’: he never allows them to grow i…"
"They are supposed to be mature, and it is on this necessary supposition that their adulthood justifiably rests."
"Education refers to no particular process; rather it encapsulates criteria to which any one of a family of processes …"
"The works of Sartre and Heidegger abound in description of the multifarious ways in which men seek to lose themselves…"
"The fundamental optimism which is an element of all true nobility … is obviously related to courage since it refuses …"