"We cannot describe how the mind is made without having good ways to describe complicated processes. Before computers, no languages were good for that. Piaget tried algebra and Freud tried diagrams; other psychologists used Markov Chains and matrices, but none came to much. Behaviorists, quite properly, had ceased to speak at all. Linguists flocked to formal syntax, and made progress for a time but reached a limit: transformational grammar shows the contents of the registers (so to speak), but has no way to describe what controls them. This makes it hard to say how surface speech relates to underlying designation and intent–a baby-and-bath-water situation. I prefer ideas from AI research because there we tend to seek procedural description first, which seems more appropriate for mental matters."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Marvin Minsky, in "Music, Mind, and Meaning" (1981)
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Psychology
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Psychology
40 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Psychology →
Related Quotes
"Astrology is to exact astronomy what psychology is to exact physiology. In astrology and psychology one has to step b…"
"When psychology and physiology become worthy of the name of sciences, Europeans will be convinced of the weird and fo…"
"Neglected as psychology now is, and with the strangely chaotic state in which physiology is confessed to be by its mo…"
"Modern psychology at its best has a questionable understanding of the soul. It has no place for the natural superiori…"
"There is one view that we can allow these AI [tools] to deal with data and analytics and we let people deal with the …"
"To judge from current writing, psychology has pretty well demolished the private conscience. University professors ca…"
"Psychology appeared to be a jungle of confusing, conflicting, and arbitrary concepts. These pre-scientific theories d…"
"Unlike the physicist, the psychologist … investigates processes that belong to the same order — perception, learning,…"
"Psychology has a long past, but only a short history."
"Psychology, or the great, and in our days, so neglected science of the soul, both as an entity distinct from the spir…"