"In part, the character of Protestantism was shaped by its revolutionary character. Rather than reforming the established church of the West, it instigated a revolution that claimed to start Christianity anew, renewed, and reformed, a millennium and a half after its beginning. Because Protestantism developed as a revolt against an institution and a tradition it rightly recognized as corrupt, Protestantism had a natural critical regard of institutional religion and tradition. It was not able to take up the Tradition of the first millennium. Because of its critical stance towards Tradition, it found itself committed in the end to its own secularization, a point well made by the scholar of comparative religions, Rene Guenon (1886-1951). Actually, religion being essentially a form of tradition the anti-traditional spirit cannot help being anti-religious; it begins by denaturing religion nd ends by suppressing it altogether, wherever it is able to do so. Protestantism is illogical from the fact that, while doing its utmost to “humanize” religion, it nevertheless permits the survival, at least theoretically, of a supra-human element, namely revelation; it hesitates to drive negation to its logical conclusion, but, by exposing revelation to all the discussions which follow in the wake of purely human interpretations, it does in fact reduce it practically to nothing .. It is natural that Protestantism, animated as it is by a spirit of negation, should have given birth to that dissolving “criticism” which in the hand of so-called “historians of religion,” has become a weapon of offense against all religion; in this way, while affecting not to recognize any authority except that of the Scriptures, it has itself contributed in large measure to the destruction of the very same authority, of the minimum of tradition, that is to say, which is still affected to retain; once launched, the revolt against the traditional outlook could not be arrested in mid-course."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Rene Guenon, Crisis of the Modern World (London: Luzac and Co., 1975), pp. 58-59
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Protestantism
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Protestantism
45 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Protestantism →
Related Quotes
"By this time, Portugal had already lost its exclusive hold on Africa, and more colonizing nations of Europe were bidd…"
"Previous studies have examined the causal link between Protestantism and democratization, primarily in shaping a nati…"
"Rarely does a historian venture solutions. But I offer one here. In an era when some are asking again what can we do …"
"Although they left Protestants back in Europe, Jesuits of that second wave of evangelization never encountered their …"
"Protestant theologians and political theorists are profoundly suspicious of the natural law approach, an attitude whi…"
"In Catholic doctrine, divine revelation did not end with the scriptures, but continued from age to age through the me…"
"Radical Protestants have always been concerned for the inwardly authentic quality of personal experience and commitme…"
"Because their acts of racism often have been so violent and blatant, discussions of racism over the years have center…"
"Protestantism itself, in its early phases, was plainly a movement toward mysticism: its purpose, at least in theory, …"
"For what is specific in the Catholic religion is immortalization and not justification, in the Protestant sense. Rath…"