"So we encounter the strategy exemplified by Morris: Talk generally about design, pattern, purpose, and beauty in nature. There are many examples of adaptations that can be used—the wings of bats or “the amazing circulatory system,” for example. But what happens if we press some more difficult cases? Well, if there seems to be no design or purpose to a feature (and if its presence cannot be understood as a modification of ancestral characters), one can always point out that some parts of the Creator’s plan may be too vast for human understanding. We do not see what the design is, but there is design, nonetheless. Since no plan of design has been specified, Creationists have available another all-purpose escape clause. But it is precisely this feature of Creation “science” that impugns its scientific credentials. To mumble that “the ways of the creator are many and mysterious” may excuse one from identifying design in unlikely places. It is not to do science."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Philosophers from EnglandBiographers from the United KingdomAcademics from the United KingdomNon-fiction authors from EnglandSkeptics
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Chapter 5, “What Price Creationism?” (p. 138)
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Philip_Kitcher
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Philip Kitcher
31 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Philip Kitcher →
Related Quotes
"Creationist strategy is often to run entirely different issues together, to concoct a muddy paste out of distinct all…"
"The book that follows is a chase. The Creationist is allowed to choose one battleground after another. Given each cho…"
"Creationists are actually criticizing methods that are used throughout science. As I shall argue extensively, there i…"
"Ironically, philosophers of science owe the Creationists a debt. For the “scientific” Creationists have constructed a…"
"In almost any natural population of organisms, more offspring will be produced than are able to survive. The offsprin…"
"Evolutionary change is change in the genetic constitution of a population. This type of change can come about as a re…"
"Do the doctrine’s problem-solving strategies encounter recurrent difficulties in a significant range of cases? Are th…"
"Consistency is not the hobgoblin of the Creationist mind."
"The road to Creationism is paved with bad philosophy."
"Even if Creationists continue to lose in the courts, they may still succeed in wreaking havoc upon science education …"