"I grew to understand how the Chicago School argued, and I can do it myself, but they were lying about how they arrived at their conclusions. I could see that they were obviously lying, but I was just annoyed and shocked that they continued to lie about how they got to the questions that they got to. And then it gradually occurred to me that if this is true, then maybe the whole profession is lying, and that belief has gotten stronger as I have gotten older. People say, "We do econometrics, and that tests our hypotheses." Baloney. We do theory. I was just rereading last night Paul Krugman's famous article where he tries to introduce geographical considerations into economics, and it is a very skillfully done article. It's rhetorically very skillful. I can show you how it works rhetorically, but it is complete nonsense scientifically, not because it is wrong but because it is arbitrary. There are a zillion other ways of formalizing geography in economics that would come to opposite conclusions to those he comes to, and yet he's kind of airily saying that this is a contribution. Then there are a thousand other articles modifying that. It doesn't get anywhere: they modify it and get completely different conclusions. If you change your assumptions, you get different theorems. So the whole exercise, it gradually dawned on me, was complete nonsense, so that's what turned me. But it is unfair and kind of stupid to say that I stopped doing economics."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Academics from the United StatesEssayists from the United StatesColumnists from the United StatesBloggers from the United StatesEconomists from the United States
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Paul Krugman
154 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Paul Krugman →
Related Quotes
"If there were an Economist's Creed, it would surely contain the affirmations 'I understand the Principle of Comparati…"
"If there is one single area of economics in which path dependence is unmistakable, it is in economic geography – the …"
"In the course of describing my formative moment in 1978, I have already implicitly given my four basic rules for rese…"
"I do not mean to say that formal economic analysis is worthless, and that anybody's opinion on economic matters is as…"
"But the honest truth is that what drives me as an economist is that economics is fun. I think I understand why so man…"
"If you want a simple model for predicting the unemployment rate in the United States over the next few years, here it…"
"If economists ruled the world, there would be no need for a World Trade Organization. The economist's case for free t…"
"It is a bit funny, but also quite sad: Those who preach the doctrine of global glut are tilting at windmills, when th…"
"The idea of comparative advantage—with its implication that trade between two nations normally raises the real income…"
"The Sanders campaign has brought out a lot of idealism and energy that the progressive movement needs. It has also, h…"