"I quote somewhere a correspondence with Ken Arrow, after he wrote Arrow and Hahn. I wrote to him and I said that the trouble is that neoclassical economists confuse risk with uncertainty. Uncertainty means non-probabilistic. And he said, 'Quite true, you're quite correct that Keynes is much more fruitful, but the trouble with the General Theory is, those things that were fruitful couldn't be developed into a nice precise analytical statement, and those things that could were retrogressions from Keynes but could be developed into a nice precise analytical statement.' That's why mainstream economics went that route. And my answer is, I would hope that even Nobel Prize winners didn't believe that regression is growth, which it clearly isn't. But that's right. The fear that everybody has, you see, is nihilism: you won't be able to say what's going to happen . Well, evolutionists don't worry about being unable to predict. You ask the evolutionists, who tell you what happened in the past, just what next species is going to appear, and the answer is, anything could. Right? Does that bother people? Explanation is the first thing in science. If you can't explain, you don't have anything. But you needn't necessarily predict. Now, if you know the future's uncertain, what does that mean? It means basically, the way Hicks put it in his later years, that humans have free will. The human system isn't deterministic or stochastic, which is deterministic with a random error. Humans can do thins to change the world."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
quoted in Conversations with Post Keynesians (1995) by J. E. King
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Paul_Davidson_(economist)
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Paul Davidson (economist)
Paul Davidson (October 23, 1930 – June 20, 2024) was an American macroeconomist who was one of the leading spokesmen of the American branch of the Post Keynesian school in economics. He was a prolific writer and had actively intervened in important debates on economic policy (natural resources, international monetary system, developing countries' debt) from a position that is very critical of mainstream economics.
2 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Paul Davidson (economist) →
Related Quotes
"Then what you find out is, what humans then do is, they create institutions - that's where institutionalism has a tie…"
"It is very unlikely that we would drive to extinction any native Martian microorganisms in the process of extending t…"
"We do not need a lunar-orbiting station to go to the Moon. We do not need such a station to go to Mars. We do not nee…"
"Musk can probably build a giant AI data centre on the Moon. But if it can’t compete with much cheaper alternatives on…"
"Much of the uncertainty in individual decision making comes from not knowing what we really want to achieve through t…"
"The better is the worst enemy of the plenty good enough."
"So the road to a decision involves five steps, each simple enough: list of the actions you can take (a decision is ju…"
"People seem to flinch at the word probability—it has too many syllables. Besides, it sounds mathematical, and it’s be…"
"Someone once said that he had made many mistakes in life, but never because he knew too much."
"There may be people who know more than you, and can therefore do a better job of predicting the odds. If you can find…"